1. Inspired by the recent Worst Song topic, I was asking which one do you consider the best and the worst album.

    In order to rate them I'm gonna do a complete review with ratings for each song. It is a considerable work, so if you want to, you can quote my original message in order to avoid writing it all again.


    I rate each song by the quality itself, not compared with any other. That's why Twilight gets the same rating as All Because Of You...


    **I don't count Under A Blood Red Sky nor Wide Awake In America**

    -----------------------------------------------------------------

    Boy

    I WIll Follow..............................= 10 / 10
    Twilight....................................=7,5 / 10
    An Cat Dubh............................= 6,5 / 10
    Into The Heart..........................= 6,5 / 10
    Out Of Control..........................= 9 / 10
    Stories For Boys.....................= 7 / 10
    The Ocean...............................= 8 / 10
    A Day Without Me....................= 7 / 10
    Another Time, Another Place..= 7 / 10
    The Electric Co........................= 8,5 / 10
    Shadows And Tall Trees........= 7,5 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,68


    October

    Gloria......................................= 8,5 / 10
    I Falll Down ............................= 7 / 10
    I Threw A Brick Through... ....= 6,5 / 10
    Rejoice....................................= 6 / 10
    Fire..........................................= 6,5 / 10
    Tomorrow...............................= 6 / 10
    October...................................= 10 / 10
    With A Shout (Jer.) ................= 6 / 10
    Stranger In A Strange Land....= 6,5 / 10
    Scarlet.....................................= 6,5 / 10
    Is That All?..............................= 5,5 / 10

    Average................................. = 6,81


    War

    Sunday Bloody Sunday..........= 9 / 10
    New Year's Day.....................= 8 / 10
    Seconds.................................= 7,5 / 10
    Like A Song............................= 8 / 10
    Drowning Man........................= 6,5 / 10
    The Refugee...........................= 6,5 / 10
    Two Hearts Beat As One.......= 7,5 / 10
    Red Light.................................= 7 / 10
    Surrender................................= 8 / 10
    ''40''..........................................= 8 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,63


    The Unforgettable Fire

    A Sort Of Homecoming .........= 8,5 / 10
    Pride (In The Name of Love)...= 10 / 10
    Wire........................................= 7,5 / 10
    The Unforgettable Fire ..........= 8 / 10
    Promenade.............................= 7 / 10
    4th of July..............................= 6 / 10
    Bad........................................= 10 / 10
    Indian Summer Sky................= 7,5 / 10
    Elvis Presley And America....= 6,5 / 10
    MLK.......................................= 9 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,00


    The Joshua Tree

    Where The Streets Have... ...= 10 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What... ..= 8,5 / 10
    With Or Without You..............= 9 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky ...............= 9 / 10
    Running To Stand Still............= 8 / 10
    Red Hill Mining Town..............= 8 / 10
    In God's Country....................= 8/ 10
    Trip Through your Wires........= 7,5 / 10
    One Tree Hill..........................= 8 / 10
    Exit ........................................= 7,5 / 10
    Mother Of The Disappeared...= 8,5 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,36


    Rattle And Hum

    Helter Skelter..........................= No rating (cover version)
    Van Diemen's Land................= 7 / 10
    Desire.....................................= 9 / 10
    Hawkmoon 269.......................= 8 / 10
    All Along The Watchtower.....= No rating (cover version)
    I Still Haven't Found What... ...= 9 / 10
    Freedom For My People..........= No rating (Not U2 song)
    Silver And Gold.......................= 8 / 10
    Pride (In The Name Of Love)..= 9 / 10
    Angel Of Harlem.....................= 8,5 / 10
    Love Rescue Me.....................= 8 / 10
    When love Comes To Town...= 8,5 / 10
    Heartland................................= 8 / 10
    God Part II...............................= 8 / 10
    The Starspangled Banner.......= No rating (cover version)
    Bullet The Blue Sky ................= 8,5 / 10
    All I Want Is You......................= 10 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,42


    Achtung Baby

    Zoo Station............................= 8,5 / 10
    Even Better Than The Real... = 8 / 10
    One........................................= 9 / 10
    Until The End Of The World ...= 8 / 10
    Who's Gonna Ride Your W... = 7,5 / 10
    So Cruel ................................= 9 / 10
    The Fly...................................= 8 / 10
    Mysterious Ways...................= 8,5 / 10
    Tryin' To Throw Your Arms...= 8,5 / 10
    Ultraviolet................................= 8 / 10
    Acrobat..................................= 9 / 10
    Love Is Blindness...................= 10 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,50


    Zooropa

    Zooropa..................................= 8,5 / 10
    Babyface................................= 7,5 / 10
    Numb.......................................= 6 / 10
    Lemon.....................................= 8 / 10
    Stay........................................= 9 / 10
    Daddy's Gonna Pay For.. ......= 8 / 10
    Some Days Are Better... .......= 7 / 10
    The First Time.........................= 8 / 10
    Dirty Day................................= 9 / 10
    The Wanderer........................= 7 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,16


    PoP

    Discoteque.............................= 8 / 10
    Do You Feel Loved................= 7,5 / 10
    Mofo.......................................= 9 / 10
    If God Will Send His Angels....= 8 / 10
    Staring At The Sun..................= 8,5 / 10
    Last Night On Earth.................= 8 / 10
    Gone.......................................= 8,5 / 10
    Miami.......................................= 7,5 / 10
    The Playboy Mansion..............= 8 / 10
    If You Wear That Velvet... .....= 6,5 / 10
    Please.....................................= 9,5 / 10
    Wake Up Dead Man................= 9 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,16


    All That You Can't Leave Behind

    Beautiful Day..........................= 8,5 / 10
    Stuck in A Moment.................= 7 / 10
    Elevation.................................= 9 / 10
    Walk On..................................= 10 / 10
    Kite.........................................= 8,5 / 10
    In A Little While.......................= 7,5 / 10
    Wild Honey.............................= 7 / 10
    Peace On Earth......................= 9 / 10
    When I Look At The World......= 7,5 / 10
    New York...............................= 7 / 10
    Grace.....................................= 7 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,00

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

    Vertigo....................................= 8 / 10
    Miracle Drug...........................= 8 / 10
    Sometimes You Can't Make... = 8,5 / 10
    Love And Peace Or Else........= 8 / 10
    City Of Blinding Lights............= 9,5 / 10
    All Because Of You...............= 7,5 / 10
    A Man And A Woman.............= 7 / 10
    Crumbs From Your Table.......= 7,5 / 10
    One Step Closer.....................= 6 / 10
    Original Of The Species.........= 8,5 / 10
    Yahweh.................................= 8 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,86


    -----------------------------------------------------------------
    So the best album resulted to be Achtung Baby, followed very nearly by the late 80's, represented by Rattle and Hum and The Johua Tree.

    And the worst one resulted to be the album October...
    -----------------------------------------------------------------


    I don't ask you to agree with me or to answer to particular song ratings... Just give your opinion.


    Thanks to the ones who wish to participate!


  2. I don't know about averages (and how to calculate them!) so I'll just say a percent of 100.

    Boy

    I WIll Follow..............................= 10 / 10
    Twilight....................................=10 / 10
    An Cat Dubh............................= 10 / 10
    Into The Heart..........................= 10 / 10
    Out Of Control..........................= 10 / 10
    Stories For Boys.....................= 10 / 10
    The Ocean...............................= 1 / 10
    A Day Without Me....................= 10 / 10
    Another Time, Another Place..= 6 / 10
    The Electric Co........................= 10 / 10
    Shadows And Tall Trees........= 6.5 / 10

    65%


    October

    Gloria......................................= 9,5 / 10
    I Falll Down ............................= 1 / 10
    I Threw A Brick Through... ....= 1 / 10
    Rejoice....................................= 1 / 10
    Fire..........................................= 1 / 10
    Tomorrow...............................= 1 / 10
    October...................................= 6 / 10
    With A Shout (Jer.) ................= 1 / 10
    Stranger In A Strange Land....= 1 / 10
    Scarlet.....................................= 1 / 10
    Is That All?..............................= 1 / 10

    25% (poor)


    War

    Sunday Bloody Sunday..........= 10/10
    New Year's Day.....................= 10 / 10
    Seconds.................................= 10 / 10
    Like A Song............................= 0 / 10
    Drowning Man........................= 0 / 10
    The Refugee...........................= 0 / 10
    Two Hearts Beat As One.......= 0 / 10
    Red Light.................................= 0 / 10
    Surrender................................= 6 / 10
    ''40''..........................................= 9.9 / 10

    60%


    The Unforgettable Fire

    A Sort Of Homecoming .........= 9 / 10
    Pride (In The Name of Love)...= 10 / 10
    Wire........................................= 9 / 10
    The Unforgettable Fire ..........= 9 / 10
    Promenade.............................= 7 / 10
    4th of July..............................= 6 / 10
    Bad........................................= 10 / 10
    Indian Summer Sky................= 7,5 / 10
    Elvis Presley And America....= 6,5 / 10
    MLK.......................................= 10 / 10

    80%


    The Joshua Tree

    Where The Streets Have... ...= 10 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What... ..=10 / 10
    With Or Without You..............= 10 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky ...............= 10 / 10
    Running To Stand Still............= 10 / 10
    Red Hill Mining Town..............= 10 / 10
    In God's Country....................= 10 / 10
    Trip Through your Wires........= 10 / 10
    One Tree Hill..........................= 10 / 10
    Exit ........................................= 10 / 10
    Mother Of The Disappeared...= 10 / 10

    100%


    Rattle And Hum

    Helter Skelter..........................= 9/10
    Van Diemen's Land................= 6 / 10
    Desire.....................................= 10 / 10
    Hawkmoon 269.......................= 8 / 10
    All Along The Watchtower.....= 9/10
    I Still Haven't Found What... ...= 10/10
    Freedom For My People..........= 4/10
    Silver And Gold.......................= 8 / 10
    Pride (In The Name Of Love)..= 10/10
    Angel Of Harlem.....................= 8 / 10
    Love Rescue Me.....................= 9 / 10
    When love Comes To Town...= 10 / 10
    Heartland................................= 7 / 10
    God Part II...............................= 8 / 10
    The Starspangled Banner.......= 2/10
    Bullet The Blue Sky ................= 10 / 10
    All I Want Is You......................= 10 / 10

    88%


    Achtung Baby

    Zoo Station............................= 9 / 10
    Even Better Than The Real... = 9 / 10
    One........................................= 5 / 10
    Until The End Of The World ...= 10 / 10
    Who's Gonna Ride Your W... = 3 / 10
    So Cruel ................................= 3 / 10
    The Fly...................................= 9 / 10
    Mysterious Ways...................= 7 / 10
    Tryin' To Throw Your Arms...= 7 / 10
    Ultraviolet................................= 6 / 10
    Acrobat..................................= 5 / 10
    Love Is Blindness...................= 10 / 10

    91%


    Zooropa

    Zooropa..................................= 10 / 10
    Babyface................................= 4 / 10
    Numb.......................................= 10 / 10
    Lemon.....................................= 10 / 10
    Stay........................................= 10 / 10
    Daddy's Gonna Pay For.. ......= 9.5 / 10
    Some Days Are Better... .......= 10 / 10
    The First Time.........................= 1 / 10
    Dirty Day................................= 1 / 10
    The Wanderer........................= 4 / 10

    80%


    PoP

    Discoteque.............................= 10 / 10
    Do You Feel Loved................= 10 / 10
    Mofo.......................................= 10 / 10
    If God Will Send His Angels....= 10 / 10
    Staring At The Sun..................= 10 / 10
    Last Night On Earth.................= 10 / 10
    Gone.......................................= 10 / 10
    Miami.......................................= 10 / 10
    The Playboy Mansion..............= 10 / 10
    If You Wear That Velvet... .....= 10 / 10
    Please.....................................= 10 / 10
    Wake Up Dead Man................= 10 / 10

    100%


    All That You Can't Leave Behind

    Beautiful Day..........................= 7 / 10
    Stuck in A Moment.................= 8.5 / 10
    Elevation.................................= 9 / 10
    Walk On..................................= 10 / 10
    Kite.........................................= 10 / 10
    In A Little While.......................= 10 / 10
    Wild Honey.............................= 6 / 10
    Peace On Earth......................= 4 / 10
    When I Look At The World......= 8 / 10
    New York...............................= 5 / 10
    Grace.....................................= 5 / 10

    75%

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

    Vertigo....................................= 7 / 10
    Miracle Drug...........................= 9 / 10
    Sometimes You Can't Make... = 10/ 10
    Love And Peace Or Else........= 8 / 10
    City Of Blinding Lights............= 9.5 / 10
    All Because Of You...............= 9.5 / 10
    A Man And A Woman.............= 9 / 10
    Crumbs From Your Table.......= 10 / 10
    One Step Closer.....................= 7 / 10
    Original Of The Species.........= 9 / 10
    Yahweh.................................= 8 / 10

    80%
  3. Originally posted by drewhigginsI don't know about averages (and how to calculate them!) so I'll just say a percent of 100.
    Well, you just add 10 + 6 + 7 + 8,5 + 5... and later you divide all you got (116,5) between the number of things added (14) and gives you the average (7,84)...
    Originally posted by drewPoP

    Discoteque.............................= 10 / 10
    (...)
    Wake Up Dead Man................= 10 / 10

    100%
    Wow... A bit high, don't you think?
    And what about a 0 for Like A Song and Two Hearts Beat? And a 5 for Acrobat? And a 3 for So Cruel? And a 1 for Dirty Day?
  4. Let's see, this should be more fun than getting some work done.

    NOTE: Only albums versions counted, no potential versions...

    Boy

    I WIll Follow = 8 / 10
    Twilight = 9 / 10
    An Cat Dubh = 5 / 10
    Into The Heart = 6 / 10
    Out Of Control = 9 / 10
    Stories For Boys = 9 / 10
    The Ocean = 5 / 10
    A Day Without Me = 10 / 10
    Another Time, Another Place = 9 / 10
    The Electric Co = 9 / 10
    Shadows And Tall Trees = 8 / 10

    Average: 7,91


    October

    Gloria = 8 / 10
    I Falll Down = 7 / 10
    I Threw A Brick Through... = 8 / 10
    Rejoice = 9 / 10
    Fire = 5/ 10
    Tomorrow = 10 / 10
    October = 5/ 10
    With A Shout (Jer.) = 5 / 10
    Stranger In A Strange Land = 5 / 10
    Scarlet = 6 / 10
    Is That All? = 5 / 10

    Average: 6,64

    War

    Sunday Bloody Sunday = 10 / 10
    New Year's Day = 8 / 10
    Seconds = 9/ 10
    Like A Song = 10/ 10
    Drowning Man = 8 / 10
    The Refugee = 5 / 10
    Two Hearts Beat As One = 10/ 10
    Red Light = 6 / 10
    Surrender = 7/ 10
    ''40'' = 8 / 10

    Average: 8,1

    The Unforgettable Fire

    A Sort Of Homecoming = 9 / 10
    Pride (In The Name of Love) = 6 / 10
    Wire = 5 / 10
    The Unforgettable Fire = 8 / 10
    Promenade = 6 / 10
    4th of July = 5 / 10
    Bad = 7 / 10
    Indian Summer Sky = 7 / 10
    Elvis Presley And America = 6 / 10
    MLK = 3 / 10

    Average: 6,2

    The Joshua Tree

    Where The Streets Have... = 8/ 10
    I Still Haven't Found What... = 8 / 10
    With Or Without You = 10 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky = 10 / 10
    Running To Stand Still = 8 / 10
    Red Hill Mining Town = 7 / 10
    In God's Country = 8/ 10
    Trip Through your Wires = 5 / 10
    One Tree Hill = 8 / 10
    Exit = 9 / 10
    Mother Of The Disappeared = 8 / 10

    Average: 8,09

    Rattle And Hum

    Van Diemen's Land = 8 / 10
    Desire = 7 / 10
    Hawkmoon 269 = 7 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What... = 8 / 10
    Silver And Gold = 9 / 10
    Pride (In The Name Of Love) = 6 / 10
    Angel Of Harlem = 7,5 / 10
    Love Rescue Me = 8 / 10
    When love Comes To Town = 7/ 10
    Heartland = 9 / 10
    God Part II = 8 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky = 8,5 / 10
    All I Want Is You = 10 / 10

    Average: 7,92

    Achtung Baby

    Zoo Station = 8 / 10
    Even Better Than The Real... = 9 / 10
    One = 10 / 10
    Until The End Of The World = 8 / 10
    Who's Gonna Ride Your W... = 8 / 10
    So Cruel = 9 / 10
    The Fly = 8 / 10
    Mysterious Ways = 8 / 10
    Tryin' To Throw Your Arms...= 8 / 10
    Ultraviolet = 10/ 10
    Acrobat = 9 / 10
    Love Is Blindness = 9 / 10

    Average: 8,67

    Zooropa

    Zooropa = 8 / 10
    Babyface = 8 / 10
    Numb = 8 / 10
    Lemon = 8 / 10
    Stay = 8 / 10
    Daddy's Gonna Pay For.. = 8 / 10
    Some Days Are Better... = 8 / 10
    The First Time = 8 / 10
    Dirty Day = 10 / 10

    Average: 8,22

    PoP

    Discoteque = 9 / 10
    Do You Feel Loved = 8 / 10
    Mofo = 8 / 10
    If God Will Send His Angels = 8 / 10
    Staring At The Sun = 7 / 10
    Last Night On Earth = 10 / 10
    Gone = 8 / 10
    Miami = 9 / 10
    The Playboy Mansion = 8 / 10
    If You Wear That Velvet... = 8 / 10
    Please = 10 / 10
    Wake Up Dead Man = 9 / 10

    Average: 8,5

    All That You Can't Leave Behind

    Beautiful Day = 7 / 10
    Stuck in A Moment = 3 / 10
    Elevation = 5 / 10
    Walk On = 8 / 10
    Kite = 6 / 10
    In A Little While = 8 / 10
    Wild Honey = 7 / 10
    Peace On Earth = 6 / 10
    When I Look At The World = 9 / 10
    New York = 7 / 10
    Grace = 8 / 10

    Average: 6,72

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

    Vertigo = 7 / 10
    Miracle Drug = 7 / 10
    Sometimes You Can't Make... = 7 / 10
    Love And Peace Or Else = 8 / 10
    City Of Blinding Lights = 8 / 10
    All Because Of You = 5 / 10
    A Man And A Woman = 7 / 10
    Crumbs From Your Table = 3 / 10
    One Step Closer = 8 / 10
    Original Of The Species = 8 / 10
    Yahweh = 9 / 10

    Average: 7

    So, following this list, my favourite album is Achtung Baby, followed by Pop and Zooropa.
    My least favourite The Unforgettable Fire followed by October and All that you can't leave behind...
  5. Originally posted by yeahLet's see, this should be more fun than getting some work done.



    Your notes are very similar to mine... Nice!
  6. Boy

    I WIll Follow = 8 / 10
    Twilight = 10 / 10
    An Cat Dubh = 10 / 10
    Into The Heart = 10 / 10
    Out Of Control = 8 / 10
    Stories For Boys = 9 / 10
    The Ocean = 8 / 10
    A Day Without Me = 8 / 10
    Another Time, Another Place = 7 / 10
    The Electric Co = 9 / 10
    Shadows And Tall Trees = 9 / 10

    October

    Gloria = 9 / 10
    I Falll Down = 7 / 10
    I Threw A Brick Through A Window = 7 / 10
    Rejoice = 6 / 10
    Fire = 7 / 10
    Tomorrow = 9 / 10
    October = 10 / 10
    With A Shout (Jerusalem) = 7 / 10
    Stranger In A Strange Land = 8 / 10
    Scarlet = 7 / 10
    Is That All? = 5 / 10

    War

    Sunday Bloody Sunday = 9 / 10
    Seconds = 8 / 10
    New Year's Day = 8 / 10
    Like A Song = 8 / 10
    Drowning Man = 9 / 10
    The Refugee = 7 / 10
    Two Hearts Beat As One = 10 / 10
    Red Light = 7 / 10
    Surrender = 10 / 10
    ''40'' = 9 / 10

    The Unforgettable Fire

    A Sort Of Homecoming = 10 / 10
    Pride (In The Name of Love) = 10 / 10
    Wire = 10 / 10
    The Unforgettable Fire = 10 / 10
    Promenade = 10 / 10
    4th of July = 10 / 10
    Bad = 10 / 10
    Indian Summer Sky = 10 / 10
    Elvis Presley And America = 10 / 10
    MLK = 10 / 10

    The Joshua Tree

    Where The Streets Have No Name = 10 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For = 8 / 10
    With Or Without You = 9 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky = 9 / 10
    Running To Stand Still = 10 / 10
    Red Hill Mining Town = 10 / 10
    In God's Country = 10 / 10
    Trip Through Your Wires = 7 / 10
    One Tree Hill = 10 / 10
    Exit = 9 / 10
    Mother Of The Disappeared = 8 / 10

    Rattle And Hum

    Van Diemen's Land = 8 / 10
    Desire = 8 / 10
    Hawkmoon 269 = 7 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For (Live) = 7 / 10
    Silver And Gold (Live) = 8 / 10
    Pride (In The Name Of Love) (Live) = 7 / 10
    Angel Of Harlem = 8 / 10
    Love Rescue Me = 7 / 10
    When love Comes To Town = 8 / 10
    Heartland = 10 / 10
    God Part II = 8 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky = 8 / 10
    All I Want Is You = 10 / 10

    Achtung Baby

    Zoo Station = 8 / 10
    Even Better Than The Real Thing = 8 / 10
    One = 6 / 10
    Until The End Of The World = 8 / 10
    Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses = 9 / 10
    So Cruel = 7 / 10
    The Fly = 8 / 10
    Mysterious Ways = 9 / 10
    Tryin' To Throw Your Arms = 8 / 10
    Ultraviolet (Light My Way) = 8 / 10
    Acrobat = 8 / 10
    Love Is Blindness = 9 / 10

    Zooropa

    Zooropa = 10 / 10
    Babyface = 8 / 10
    Numb = 7 / 10
    Lemon = 8 / 10
    Stay = 9 / 10
    Daddy's Gonna Pay For Crashed Car = 8 / 10
    Some Days Are Better = 6 / 10
    The First Time = 8 / 10
    Dirty Day = 8 / 10
    The Wanderer = 5 / 10

    Pop

    Discotheque = 9 / 10
    Do You Feel Loved = 8 / 10
    Mofo = 8 / 10
    If God Will Send His Angels = 9 / 10
    Staring At The Sun = 8 / 10
    Last Night On Earth = 9 / 10
    Gone = 10 / 10
    Miami= 8 / 10
    The Playboy Mansion = 7 / 10
    If You Wear That Velvet Dress = 9 / 10
    Please = 10 / 10
    Wake Up Dead Man = 9 / 10

    All That You Can't Leave Behind

    Beautiful Day = 7 / 10
    Stuck in A Moment = 6 / 10
    Elevation = 8 / 10
    Walk On = 9 / 10
    Kite = 9 / 10
    In A Little While = 8 / 10
    Wild Honey = 7 / 10
    Peace On Earth = 8 / 10
    When I Look At The World = 10 / 10
    New York = 9 / 10
    Grace = 7 / 10

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

    Vertigo = 8 / 10
    Miracle Drug = 8 / 10
    Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own = 9 / 10
    Love And Peace Or Else = 8 / 10
    City Of Blinding Lights = 9 / 10
    All Because Of You = 8 / 10
    A Man And A Woman = 8 / 10
    Crumbs From Your Table = 9 / 10
    One Step Closer = 9 / 10
    Original Of The Species = 9 / 10
    Yahweh = 8 / 10

    Without a doubt, my favorite album is The Unforgettable Fire, followed by The Joshua Tree and Pop.

    My least favorite is All That You Can't Leave Behind, followed by Rattle and Hum and after, by Achtung Baby
  7. Originally posted by theedge123

    Ultraviolet (Light My Way) = 8 / 10




    only 8/10 ....... surely thats a 10/10


  8. Originally posted by dogpoleonly 8/10 ....... surely thats a 10/10



    Show us your full ratings dude!!
  9. -----------------------------------------------------------------

    Boy

    I WIll Follow..............................= 9/ 10
    Twilight....................................=7 / 10
    An Cat Dubh............................= 7 / 10
    Into The Heart..........................= 7 / 10
    Out Of Control..........................=10/ 10
    Stories For Boys.....................= 7 / 10
    The Ocean...............................= 8 / 10
    A Day Without Me....................= 6 / 10
    Another Time, Another Place..= 7 / 10
    The Electric Co........................= 9,5 / 10
    Shadows And Tall Trees........= 7,5 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,72


    October

    Gloria......................................= 9,5/ 10
    I Falll Down ............................= 6,5 / 10
    I Threw A Brick Through... ....= 7 / 10
    Rejoice....................................= 8 / 10
    Fire..........................................= 5/ 10
    Tomorrow...............................= 10 / 10
    October...................................= 10 / 10
    With A Shout (Jer.) ................= 6,5 / 10
    Stranger In A Strange Land....= 7 / 10
    Scarlet.....................................= 7,5 / 10
    Is That All?..............................= 6 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,54


    War

    Sunday Bloody Sunday..........= 9,5 / 10
    New Year's Day.....................= 10 / 10
    Seconds.................................= 7,5 / 10
    Like A Song............................= 9 / 10
    Drowning Man........................= 6,5 / 10
    The Refugee...........................= 7 / 10
    Two Hearts Beat As One.......= 8 / 10
    Red Light.................................= 6/ 10
    Surrender................................= 7,5 / 10
    ''40''..........................................= 7 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,8


    The Unforgettable Fire

    A Sort Of Homecoming .........= 10 / 10
    Pride (In The Name of Love)...= 10 / 10
    Wire........................................= 8 / 10
    The Unforgettable Fire ..........= 10 / 10
    Promenade.............................= 7 / 10
    4th of July..............................= 6 / 10
    Bad........................................= 10 / 10
    Indian Summer Sky................= 6,5 / 10
    Elvis Presley And America....= 6,5 / 10
    MLK.......................................= 8,5 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,25


    The Joshua Tree

    Where The Streets Have... ...= 10 / 10
    I Still Haven't Found What... ..= 9,5 / 10
    With Or Without You..............= 9,5 / 10
    Bullet The Blue Sky ...............= 10 / 10
    Running To Stand Still............= 10 / 10
    Red Hill Mining Town..............= 8 / 10
    In God's Country....................= 9,5/ 10
    Trip Through your Wires........= 7,5 / 10
    One Tree Hill..........................= 10 / 10
    Exit ........................................= 9 / 10
    Mother Of The Disappeared...= 9 / 10

    Average................................. =9,2


    Rattle And Hum

    Helter Skelter..........................= No rating (cover version)
    Van Diemen's Land................= 8 / 10
    Desire.....................................= 9 / 10
    Hawkmoon 269.......................= 8,5 / 10
    All Along The Watchtower.....= No rating (cover version)
    I Still Haven't Found What... ...= 8 / 10
    Freedom For My People..........= No rating (Not U2 song)
    Silver And Gold.......................= 8 / 10
    Pride (In The Name Of Love)..= 10 / 10
    Angel Of Harlem.....................= 9 / 10
    Love Rescue Me.....................= 9 / 10
    When love Comes To Town...= 8,5 / 10
    Heartland................................= 10 / 10
    God Part II...............................= 9 / 10
    The Starspangled Banner.......= No rating (cover version)
    Bullet The Blue Sky ................= 10 / 10
    All I Want Is You......................= 10 / 10

    Average................................. = 9


    Achtung Baby

    Zoo Station............................= 8,5 / 10
    Even Better Than The Real... = 9 / 10
    One........................................= 10 / 10
    Until The End Of The World ...= 10 / 10
    Who's Gonna Ride Your W... = 9,5 / 10
    So Cruel ................................= 9 / 10
    The Fly...................................= 10 / 10
    Mysterious Ways...................= 10 / 10
    Tryin' To Throw Your Arms...= 9,5 / 10
    Ultraviolet................................= 10 / 10
    Acrobat..................................= 10 / 10
    Love Is Blindness...................= 10 / 10

    Average................................. = 9,6


    Zooropa

    Zooropa..................................= 10 / 10
    Babyface................................= 7,5 / 10
    Numb.......................................= 8 / 10
    Lemon.....................................= 9/ 10
    Stay........................................= 10 / 10
    Daddy's Gonna Pay For.. ......= 9 / 10
    Some Days Are Better... .......= 7 / 10
    The First Time.........................= 8 / 10
    Dirty Day................................= 9 / 10
    The Wanderer........................= 8 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,5


    PoP

    Discoteque.............................= 8 / 10
    Do You Feel Loved................= 7,5 / 10
    Mofo.......................................= 10 / 10
    If God Will Send His Angels....= 8 / 10
    Staring At The Sun..................= 9,5 / 10
    Last Night On Earth.................= 9/ 10
    Gone.......................................= 9.5 / 10
    Miami.......................................= 7,5 / 10
    The Playboy Mansion..............= 8 / 10
    If You Wear That Velvet... .....= 7,5 / 10
    Please.....................................= 10 / 10
    Wake Up Dead Man................= 9 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,6


    All That You Can't Leave Behind

    Beautiful Day..........................= 9,5 / 10
    Stuck in A Moment.................= 8 / 10
    Elevation.................................= 9 / 10
    Walk On..................................= 10 / 10
    Kite.........................................= 9 / 10
    In A Little While.......................= 9 / 10
    Wild Honey.............................= 7 / 10
    Peace On Earth......................= 8,5 / 10
    When I Look At The World......= 7,5 / 10
    New York...............................= 9 / 10
    Grace.....................................= 7 / 10

    Average................................. = 8,5

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

    Vertigo....................................= 9 / 10
    Miracle Drug...........................= 9 / 10
    Sometimes You Can't Make... = 9,5 / 10
    Love And Peace Or Else........= 8,5 / 10
    City Of Blinding Lights............= 9,5 / 10
    All Because Of You...............= 7 / 10
    A Man And A Woman.............= 7 / 10
    Crumbs From Your Table.......= 7,5 / 10
    One Step Closer.....................= 6,5 / 10
    Original Of The Species.........= 9 / 10
    Yahweh.................................= 9 / 10

    Average................................. = 7,6

    And the winner is....Achtung Baby!!!!!
  10. Originally posted by MirrorballBoyBoy
    Average................................. = 7,72

    October
    Average................................. = 7,54

    War
    Average................................. = 7,8

    The Unforgettable Fire
    Average................................. = 8,25

    The Joshua Tree
    Average................................. =9,2

    Rattle And Hum
    Average................................. = 9

    Achtung Baby
    Average................................. = 9,6

    Zooropa
    Average................................. = 8,5

    PoP
    Average................................. = 8,6

    All That You Can't Leave Behind
    Average................................. = 8,5

    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    Average................................. = 7,6

    And the winner is....Achtung Baby!!!!!
    Your results are sooo similar as mines... We have almost the same likes/dislikes...
  11. Originally posted by LikeASong[..]Your results are sooo similar as mines... We have almost the same likes/dislikes...


    Indeed Now I see! But it's so difficult to rate songs If I do this again in a week Probably The Joshua Tree is the winner
    One of the powers of U2: If you listened to one era much, and you like something different toe hear, just choose another one. And it's a choice out of much possibilities. U2 is not a band which stayed in the same sound, that's why they're my favourite
  12. Originally posted by MirrorballBoyBut it's so difficult to rate songs
    Right. it was very hard for me. Specially with the non-perfect songs as Grace, One Step Closer, etc. It's U2 stuff, so it's hard not to rate them with a 10...