I wanted to set the record straight on behalf of the members of U2 on comments made to the BBC by our much-loved and valued manager, Paul McGuinness, regarding Radiohead's decision to make the music of 'In Rainbows' available as a download, using the 'honesty box' idea for payment.
We agree with our manager that this is a head-scratching and worrisome time for many musicians who, unlike ourselves, are depending on royalty or publishing cheques to pay the rent (particularly songwriters). We also agree that it is disturbing to see internet service providers and technology companies profit from the so-called 'disintermediation' of the music business when so many music lovers are losing their jobs. And while there is no doubt that it's extremely difficult for a new artist to get the kind of investment on which U2 depended in the first few wobbly years of recording, we disagree with Paul's assessment of Radiohead's release as "having backfired to a certain extent." We think they were courageous and imaginative in trying to figure out some new relationship with their audience. Such imagination and courage are in short supply right now...they're a sacred talent and we feel blessed to be around at the same time.
With respect,
Bono
I think that it is good that BONO spoke out. And U2 ARE friends with the guys in Radiohead. I think that while McGuinness might be mildly annoyed by Bono's comments, it is healthy that ANY member of the band can publicly state whether they disagree with management on an issue in part or in whole.
And for those that were up in arms about McGuiness' comments, Bono has made the bands view clear.
Tottaly agreed with Bono!!
And with everyone else's comments!!
It is a very healthy thing from the band to stand up and speak up their opinion, when they agree and also when disagree with the comments or statements, made by someone who is related to the band and set the record straight... it is also remarkable how he speaks about Macguinness' comments, he simple says they disagree but reafirm their respect and love to him....
thanks for the post mate!
Tottaly agreed with Bono!!
And with everyone else's comments!!
It is a very healthy thing from the band to stand up and speak up their opinion, when they agree and also when disagree with the comments or statements, made by someone who is related to the band and set the record straight... it is also remarkable how he speaks about Macguinness' comments, he simple says they disagree but reafirm their respect and love to him....
thanks for the post mate!
I imagine that McGuinness knew ahead of time that Bono was writing the letter. And I imagine that a heart to heart was had. Something to the effect of 'let's not badmouth the practices of other bands... especially our friends'.
I imagine that McGuinness knew ahead of time that Bono was writing the letter. And I imagine that a heart to heart was had. Something to the effect of 'let's not badmouth the practices of other bands... especially our friends'.
I think Paul McGuiness is one of the most arrogant twats I have ever come across...I dont care how important he is to U2. Slagging off other bands is not the thing to do. I agree about a lot of his views about ISP's etc but I only agree as it seems to be cripling upcoming musicians. However I think he couldnt give a rats ass about other musicians and only cares about lining his own pockets with even more cash!
I think Paul McGuiness is one of the most arrogant twats I have ever come across...I dont care how important he is to U2. Slagging off other bands is not the thing to do. I agree about a lot of his views about ISP's etc but I only agree as it seems to be cripling upcoming musicians. However I think he couldnt give a rats ass about other musicians and only cares about lining his own pockets with even more cash!
While we're discussing how McGuinness said the thing backfired, I
have one question:
What has he done for U2?
I know he's been the manager since the early days, but what he said was wrong. You do not critisize the way a band releases an album. You don't shoot your mouth off saying it "backfired". Mr. McGuinness, what you said was bad in taste, and very disrespectful. You should apologize for what you said. Shame on you.
Also, you lost my respect. First you want to governments to regulate ISPs to stop illegal downloading. I'm sorry, but that will always go on. Plus Bill Clinton said "no" to regulating ISPs in 1995. Perhaps U2 could be managed by Bill Curbishley, someone that I think who is a much better manager. Mr. McGuinness, the music business has changed, but cut the shit. I see right through you. You're another Kit Lambert. You want to see the band do well, for your wallet. I don't care how close you think you are to this band, go away. Bono, Edge, Larry and Adam can do better off without you.
latest site news There is a phrase in Dutch that says 'stilstand is achteruitgang', which means something like doing nothing is going backwards. Doing nothing is not an option here at U2start, we are U2 fans, and U2 fans are people w.. (read more)
statistics There are currently 4,451 topics started on the forums with over 174,779 messages.
More than 12,043 fans are a member of U2start. The average age of the U2start users is 28, only users who submitted their agae are included in this figure.
new fan around us The most recent fan who registered is named rUsolo2, welcome to U2start rUsolo2! As a new user you can introduce yourself in the Welcome to U2start y'all forum.
high resolution photos We have 562 high resolution U2 photos available for you, the biggest photo collection you will find. The latest photo we've added is 'Bono performing'.
did you know? I Will Follow is the most played U2 live song, it's also the only tune that's been played on every tour till the Vertigo Tour. At the end of the Vertigo Tour, Pride (In The Name Of Love) will (probably) be the most played song.
fan of the month Every month we put an U2 fan in the spotlights, the fan of this month is user yeah. Every fan of the month has an interview with us, you can read our interview with yeah here.
news headlines We cover the news of many international U2 websites including U2.com, the most popular headline in the last two weeks was 'U2 is not enough to close Obama's TV deal' from atu2.com.
popular songs The song Where The Streets Have No Name is requested the most at our songs pages and therefore quite popular, according to the favorite song lists of our users the song Bad is the alltime favorite song.
notable live performance According to user gil_vox the song Beautiful Day from the All That You Can't Leave Behind album was greatly performed on 2001-10-10 in South Bend, Indiana.
bootleg of the month Every month we have a bootleg in the spotlights, the current one took place on 1984-11-05 in Edinburgh, Scotland. You can download this bootleg, read reviews or write your own review here. You can also join the discussion on this bootleg in our forums.
"We've started to make records now for ourselves and for our audience who do listen very carefully to all our records and who do spot the subtleties. We're the Grateful Dead of the nineties."
- Bono at the beginning of the nineties
