FEA
Active topics

  1. Funny! I just wrote "I expected something big and ended up with something enormous" in another thread. I put 5.5 because there is nothing at the moment that is speaking against this being their best album. I hope I will say the same let's say a year from now. I'm in awe!

    Actually, I think the most important thing for me is that I love it, not how it ranks among the other U2-albums.
  2. 3,5
  4. 4 stars. It's better than I hoped for, and it still grows. Time will tell if it's right up there with the classics.
  5. i've been waiting ten years for another great album....
    i really hoped this could have been the right time but, sorry, NLOTH is just like the last two album: mainstream, overproduced, boring and tired; why the hell before every song there is an useless intro of a minute!!
    however "Fez" is a great song

    p.s.: sorry for my english
  6. Thank you all for the massive voting, we'll see in a few weeks (when we publish this poll again) what the results will be then.

    After a few listens, what is your first album impression/rating? (started on 2009-02-18)

    I haven't heard it (yet) - 25.1%
    5 stars - This is the third masterpiece - 22.6%
    4 stars - Great album, better than many many others - 19.3%
    5.5 stars - How the hell did they pull this off? - 17.2%
    3 stars - Decent album, but there have been better - 10.5%
    2 stars - Not really good yet, maybe it will grow - 4.2%
    1 stars - Sorry for clicking the wrong answer - 1%

    Votes: 522