GEN
Active topics
  1. All are scored out of 5 so (5) means the album gets 5 out of 5 in my book, and so on and so forth.

    1.Achtung Baby (5)
    2.Joshua Tree (5)
    3. Unforgetable Fire (4.5)
    4. Pop (4.4)
    5. No Line on the Horizon (4.2)
    6. Zooropa (4)
    7.War (4)
    8.October (3.9)
    9.Boy (3.8)
    10. All That You Can't Leave behind (3.5)
    11. How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (3)
  2. P.S, I haven't included Rattle & Hum, Under a Blood Red Sky and Passengers as I'm only including albums with no live tracks and official albums.
  3. Achtung Baby (10)
    The Joshua Tree (10)
    Zooropa (10)
    Boy (10)
    Pop (9)
    The Unforgettable Fire (8)
    War (8)
    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb (7)
    No Line On The Horizon (6)
    October (5)
    All That You Can't Leave Behind (4)


    Passengers album is a side project and Rattle and Hum is a compliation.
  4. Originally posted by jones:Achtung Baby (10)
    The Joshua Tree (10)
    Zooropa (10)
    Boy (10)
    Pop (9)
    The Unforgettable Fire (8)
    War (8)
    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb (7)
    No Line On The Horizon (6)
    October (5)
    All That You Can't Leave Behind (4)


    Passengers album is a side project and Rattle and Hum is a compliation.


    Rattle and Hum is a true album but it is one hell of a mess.


  5. It's not a true album, it's a mix of studio and live recordings.


  6. It's still in their studio album list. Still counts.


  7. For example - Yellow Submarine is listed as a real/true studio album on most Beatles websites, but in fact it's a mix of Beatles tracks (and 2 of them were released on previous albums) and George Martin's film score. So just because they say it's a studio album, that doesn't mean it is.
  8. Originally posted by jones:[..]

    For example - Yellow Submarine is listed as a real/true studio album on most Beatles websites, but in fact it's a mix of Beatles tracks (and 2 of them were released on previous albums) and George Martin's film score. So just because they say it's a studio album, that doesn't mean it is.


    That's maybe because The Beatles and U2 are two different bands, maybe that's their opinion. But if you go on Wikipedia, it does list Rattle & Hum as a studio album. I know anyone can edit a Wikipedia but still, that's the truth. It can be listed as a studio album.
  9. From 1 to 10

    1) Achtung Baby (10)
    2) The Joshua Tree (10)
    3)How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (9)
    4) The Unforgettable Fire (8.50)
    5) War (8.50)
    6) Zooropa (8)
    7) Rattle and Hum (8)
    8) No Line on the Horizon (8)
    9) Boy (8)
    10) All That You Can't Leave Behind (7)
    11) Pop (7)
    12) October (6)
    13) Passengers (4)
  10. 1. Achtung Baby
    2. The Joshua Tree
    3. The Unforgettable Fire
    4. War
    5. Zooropa
    6. Pop
    7. All That You Can't Leave Behind
    8. Boy
    9. How To Dismantle An Aotmic Bomb
    10. No Line On The Horizon
    11. Rattle & Hum
    12. October
  11. Bump, cool topic and I'm bored.

    1. No Line on the Horizon
    2. Achtung Baby
    3. All That You Can't Leave Behind
    4. The Unforgettable Fire
    5. Pop
    6. How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
    7. Zooropa
    8. The Joshua Tree
    9. War
    10. Rattle and Hum
    11. Boy
    12. October

    Based on rating and play count in iTunes
  12. Huh. Interesting to see my list (the one from a year ago, just before yours, Fabian.)

    My top four is still the same but ATYCLB went in as my fifth favourite U2 album in our year-end list. Aside from that double-leapfrog, I don't think anything else has changed for me.