I gave it 3, because I don't think it's worse or better than the original. It's just sort of different. I think it could've been a better release but as it is, it's nothing to sneeze at either.
You Too: How would you rate the Red Hill Mining Town single? 4 stars: Good job, more than a decent release - 29.9%
3 stars: Decent, about the same as the original - 29.3%
5 stars: Amazing new version, can't wait to hear it live - 16.1%
2 stars: Some parts are OK but mostly poor - 15.3%
1 star: Poor overall job, not worth the release - 8.1%