1. Carryover from the "Worst Song" Thread Here.

    How about some alternative Lead Singles that could have worked?

    Alternate Lead Singles

    Three - Out Of Control - no changed, the only exception; they nailed it when you compare to the B-Sides
    Boy - ATAP - could have been a good radio song
    October - Gloria - unless someone wants to put forth ITABTAW (which I actually enjoy as a song!)
    War - THBAO - this song has grown on me so much
    TUF - TUF - not a lot of singles here; even my favourite song 'Bad' I don't feel would have worked as a single
    JT - IGC - has a great hook and feel and pulls you in quick
    R&H - AIWIY - I think probably the strongest new song on the album, certainly the one that resonates with most fans
    AB - UV(LMW) - was never a single, but I think is as experimental as The Fly (given that they share the same original song) to achieve the 'cutting down the Joshua Tree' metaphor
    Zooropa - S(FSC) - no real comment; just would have been I think better than Numb
    Pop - SATS - probably the most radio friendly to draw people into an amazing album
    ATYCLB - SIAMYCGOO - some might disagree with this one; it was a great song at the time that could still have been the 'U2 is back' song that was achieved with BD
    HTDAAB - ABOY - a great rocker that could have worked for that iPod commercial
    NLOTH - IGCIIDGCT - but album version. Again, like SATS to draw people in
    SOI - CR - for me, unlike GOYB and Elevation, I will intentionally put the album version on
    SOE - TLTTGYA - I'll again say, this would have drawn in the casuals.
    SOA - Mercy.....hey I can dream
  2. All these acronyms.
  3. Oh nice idea, just the thing I like. I’ll play along later today!
  4. Boy: Electric Co.
    October: Tomorrow
    War: Sunday Bloody Sunday
    Unforgettable Fire: Unforgettable Fire
    Joshua Tree: Where The Streets Have No Name
    Rattle & Hum: All I Want Is You
    Achtung Baby: Mysterious Ways
    Zooropa: Stay
    Pop: Mofo
    All That You Can't Leave Behind: Walk On
    How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb: City Of Blinding Lights
    No Line On The Horizon: Moment Of Surrender
    Songs Of Innocence: Crystal Ballroom
    Songs Of Experience: The Little Things That Give You Away
  5. Alternative lead singles that could have worked better than the actual ones:

    Boy - I Will Follow
    October - Gloria
    War - Sunday Bloody Sunday
    The Unforgettable Fire - nothing would have worked better than Pride
    The Joshua Tree - nothing would have worked better than WOWY
    Rattle And Hum - All I Want Is You
    Achtung Baby - Even Better Than The Real Thing
    Zooropa - Stay
    Pop - Gone
    ATYCLB - Elevation
    HTDAAB - nothing would have worked better than Vertigo
    NLOTH - Magnificent
    SOI - Every Breaking Wave
    SOE - Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way


    Alternative lead singles that I'd like to have in my 45rpm collection (not quite the same thing as favorite song from the album):

    Boy - I Will Follow
    October - Tomorrow
    War - Like A Song
    The Unforgettable Fire - The Unforgettable Fire
    The Joshua Tree - One Tree Hill
    Rattle And Hum - Hawkmoon 269
    Achtung Baby - Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses
    Zooropa - Stay
    Pop - Gone
    ATYCLB - The Ground Beneath Her Feet
    HTDAAB - Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
    NLOTH - Moment Of Surrender
    SOI - Cedarwood Road
    SOE - Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
  6. Originally posted by LikeASong:Alternative lead singles that could have worked better than the actual ones:

    Boy - I Will Follow
    October - Gloria
    War - Sunday Bloody Sunday
    The Unforgettable Fire - nothing would have worked better than Pride
    The Joshua Tree - nothing would have worked better than WOWY
    Rattle And Hum - All I Want Is You
    Achtung Baby - Even Better Than The Real Thing
    Zooropa - Stay
    Pop - Gone
    ATYCLB - Elevation
    HTDAAB - nothing would have worked better than Vertigo
    NLOTH - Magnificent
    SOI - Every Breaking Wave
    SOE - Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way


    Alternative lead singles that I'd like to have in my 45rpm collection (not quite the same thing as favorite song from the album):

    Boy - I Will Follow
    October - Tomorrow
    War - Like A Song
    The Unforgettable Fire - The Unforgettable Fire
    The Joshua Tree - One Tree Hill
    Rattle And Hum - Hawkmoon 269
    Achtung Baby - Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses
    Zooropa - Stay
    Pop - Gone
    ATYCLB - The Ground Beneath Her Feet
    HTDAAB - Sometimes You Can't Make It On Your Own
    NLOTH - Moment Of Surrender
    SOI - Cedarwood Road
    SOE - Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
    Hawkmoon would be a great 45!
  7. Stole Sergio's list and made some edits to save myself the typing

    Boy - I Will Follow
    October - Gloria
    War - Sunday Bloody Sunday
    The Unforgettable Fire - nothing would have worked better than Pride
    The Joshua Tree - WOWY was obviously massive, but I would argue Still Haven't Found would've been just as big - maybe with a different music video to accompany..
    Rattle And Hum - All I Want Is You
    Achtung Baby - Even Better Than The Real Thing
    Zooropa - There isn't a big single here, Numb matched what they wanted to do and Stay wouldn't have been as courageous or as representative of the album - but Stay
    Pop - Do You Feel Loved
    ATYCLB - Hate Elevation and nothing else really fits
    HTDAAB - Mercy YEAH I SAID IT
    NLOTH - Literally anything
    SOI - Crystal Ballroom, but if I can't use that, Iris
    SOE - Love Is Bigger Than Anything In Its Way
  8. JAJAJA NLOTH-Literally anything
  9. Stay is the obvious choice for Zooropa but I think Lemon would have been better than Numb.
  10. Boy: I Will Follow
    October: Gloria
    War: Like a Song... (but New Year’s Day was the best choice)
    The Unforgettable Fire: A Sort of Homecoming (but Pride was an obvious choice even if it’s not that representative)
    The Joshua Tree: I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For (but WOWY was the best choice)
    Rattle and Hum: Hawkmoon 269 or Heartland (but Desire was the best choice)
    Achtung Baby: Acrobat (The Fly was the best choice, but can you imagine Acrobat as the lead??!)
    Zooropa: Lemon
    Pop: Staring At the Sun (but Discothèque was probably the best choice)
    All That You Can’t Leave Behind: Stuck In a Moment You Can’t Get Out of (but Beautiful Day was the best choice)
    How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb: City of Blinding Lights (but Vertigo was the best choice)
    No Line On the Horizon: No Line On the Horizon
    Songs of Innocence: Every Breaking Wave
    Songs of Experience: The Little Things That Give You Away (during TJT Tour) or The Blackout (the day of the eclipse)