FEA
Active topics
  1. Wow. Now Song For Hal, Resurrection Song, Scars and Easter Parade all have exactly the same number of votes and In A Life is just slightly ahead of them.

    This is how I feel about this EP also
  2. The quality is too even to rank.
  3. This one is taking the longest for me to enjoy, today I liked it much better than last week. I am little surprised this is your favorite, mind telling why? Is it because it’s just a departure from anything else we have heard on either EP and seems like they are going for something different with Eno? I could see it as a segue into Streets live for sure
  4. I voted Coexist. It's completely different to the rest and is not typical U2 sounds. Brian back in the fold. Bono's vocal delivery in the quiet parts is great. The lyrics paint a picture.

    The rest are growing on me. This EP much better than DOA for sure.
  5. Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:I voted Coexist. It's completely different to the rest and is not typical U2 sounds. Brian back in the fold. Bono's vocal delivery in the quiet parts is great. The lyrics paint a picture.

    The rest are growing on me. This EP much better than DOA for sure.
    Makes sense - I actually fat fingered the vote and did Coexist too lol but I’m glad because I want to see an even split between all of the songs.

    I’m going to listen to this a few times today because after my second listen it is much better. This EP is far, far better imo.
  6. Resurrection Song for me. Coexist is my least favorite, but would have been the standout on most U2 releases since at least HTDAAB which has higher highs and lower lows. This is the most I've enjoyed a U2 release start to finish during the week of release since... ATYCLB? It's hard to have a clear memory of my initial impressions a quarter century later. I think I was at least somewhat into songs that I usually skip now like Peace on Earth or Grace. I don't think any of these are skippers if they come up on a shuffle.
  7. Song for Hal - a beautiful song.
  9. Easter Parade
  10. Resurrection Song currently, but In a Life is growing on me. I really enjoy the other tracks as well.

  11. Same. What a song.

    But as others have noted, I like seeing that each song has its own proponents distributed fairly evenly. Speaks to the strength of the new material.