1. Hey, i was thinking about this song and reading some posts here, i wonder, why does everybody hate this song? I mean, it has great lyrics, good vocal's, specially that live in the chapel and it has a nice melody behind it, it's clearly a good U2 song, very joshua tree, why does it seems that nobody likes it?
  2. I quite like it actually.
  3. Originally posted by Maclove:Hey, i was thinking about this song and reading some posts here, i wonder, why does everybody hate this song? I mean, it has great lyrics, good vocal's, specially that live in the chapel and it has a nice melody behind it, it's clearly a good U2 song, very joshua tree, why does it seems that nobody likes it?


    because the melody line is pretty boring and it's very obviously an outtake.
  4. It's a piano based song. I miss some guitar. Worth a try, but not the kind of arrangement I prefer from U2.

    Does the live version contain some more guitar?

    Alex
  5. it's a good non album track. i like it a lot.
  6. Rated 5 stars on my iPod

    Just to compare: WGRYWH has 3...