1. best version all tour, Vocal was amazing , turned back the years
  2. ^^

  3. For me the best version is this one in Red Rocks 1983 . Also because the beginning of the song at Red Rocks is beautiful
  4. For m it was Dublin 1987 The second night at Croke they played an extended version while Bono was getting some girl up from the crowd was a great night


  5. I have always loved this performance of NYD. I know his voice isn't in top shape but the "say its true" vocal SOARS on the Vertigo DVD. My favorite part of the song, and he just nails it.

    Similarly, on the Slane DVD, he and Edge hit perfect harmony as Bono carries out the "We can be one...." line...it makes my heart skip a beat every time. Rarely can Bono hold the note out in perfect tune long enough for Edge to match the harmony.

    I thought the down-tuned performances of the JT30 tour were sort of weak but those shows are the only time I've ever heard the song, so I'll take it.
  6. 2018 was very good. I liked the 2019 versions too. Edge played some of his parts slightly differently.
  7. In general I like the 2017 versions with the full lyrics which they didn’t carry on to 2019 missing the ‘golden age’ verse. And I loved the 2018 versions. They’re probably my 2 favourite versions in terms of in general on a tour but as a one off performance Slane is exceptional, the ‘be one’ bit when edge and Bono’s vocal sort of becomes 1 is sensational.
  8. I wasn't really a fan of the 2018 version. The intro was great but I preferred 17/19.
  9. Slane Castle is pretty amazing