1. Interesting. I guess there's no accounting for taste but are you able to put your finger on why you hated the "One" clip?
  2. Idk why but every U2 “acoustic” track ends up sounding underproduced/not well mixed. When I listen to Taylor swifts acoustic tracks, her voice has a healthy amount of reverb and is the highs/lows are well set. But like the bonus acoustic tracks on SOI and these clips, it just sounds like raw takes of drunk Bono singing along in 1 take. So far, these clips sound more “acoustic busk” than anything. With the exception of the meditation version of Streets.
  3. For me, I'm expecting that if there's about 10 decent new versions (enough to make it an albums worth) of tunes then fair enough. If more than that, it's a bonus. I can understand people's concerns though.
  4. Originally posted by Monopoly:Idk why but every U2 “acoustic” track ends up sounding underproduced/not well mixed. When I listen to Taylor swifts acoustic tracks, her voice has a healthy amount of reverb and is the highs/lows are well set. But like the bonus acoustic tracks on SOI and these clips, it just sounds like raw takes of drunk Bono singing along in 1 take. So far, these clips sound more “acoustic busk” than anything. With the exception of the meditation version of Streets.
    100% agree
  5. it's hard to unhear some of these versions once you've heard them. Could be good . Could be bad.
  6. Originally posted by Monopoly:Idk why but every U2 “acoustic” track ends up sounding underproduced/not well mixed. When I listen to Taylor swifts acoustic tracks, her voice has a healthy amount of reverb and is the highs/lows are well set. But like the bonus acoustic tracks on SOI and these clips, it just sounds like raw takes of drunk Bono singing along in 1 take. So far, these clips sound more “acoustic busk” than anything. With the exception of the meditation version of Streets.
    You have a point with Bono's vocals, I've been saying it for almost a decade now (I'd extend it to most of SOI and SOE in general, not only acoustic tracks). They seem to be going for a "raw vocal" approach, maybe for the sake of freshness, but the result is generally poor vocal takes and lines, the kind of thing you'd do when you first go into the studio to warm up and prepare the proper takes.
  7. I'm afraid the whole album will be slower, acoustic, just plain boring. So far I don't like any new version. They could have released it as a B side mix but as a new album it will be a massacre of their legacy.
  8. From the snippets I've heard so far it's gonna be a bit hit & miss. Some 're-imaginations' sound surprisingly cool (The Fly has a blues vibe for example). But I'm afraid a lot of the 40 songs are just a piano or acoustic guitar with B singing. I've yet to hear any Larry or Adam on this (and they are on the album cover).
  9. i'm facing SOS like a U2 Acoustic MTV that we never had , but more produced and without audience
  10. Originally posted by MartinPhisto:I'm afraid the whole album will be slower, acoustic, just plain boring. So far I don't like any new version. They could have released it as a B side mix but as a new album it will be a massacre of their legacy.
    the sound of 2 men chopping down their back catalogue
  11. Originally posted by melon51:From the snippets I've heard so far it's gonna be a bit hit & miss. Some 're-imaginations' sound surprisingly cool (The Fly has a blues vibe for example). But I'm afraid a lot of the 40 songs are just a piano or acoustic guitar with B singing. I've yet to hear any Larry or Adam on this (and they are on the album cover).
    It definitely sounds like Larry is in pride but literally for a few seconds, his drumming is the biggest omission in general though from what I’ve heard. I wouldn’t rule out Adam having played some of the non guitar parts on the album. Some keys and bits like that, acoustic bass maybe? Probably came up with a few ideas. Was he not playing some basic notes on some sort of mini keyboard for Yahweh on the vertigo tour?
    Edit: my minds playing tricks it was Larry doing that roll for Yahweh.
  12. Originally posted by Unodostres123:[..]
    It definitely sounds like Larry is in pride but literally for a few seconds, his drumming is the biggest omission in general though from what I’ve heard. I wouldn’t rule out Adam having played some of the non guitar parts on the album. Some keys and bits like that, acoustic bass maybe? Probably came up with a few ideas. Was he not playing some basic notes on some sort of mini keyboard for Yahweh on the vertigo tour?
    Edit: my minds playing tricks it was Larry doing that roll for Yahweh.
    Adam playing keyboard for City of... during the Vertigo Tour ?