1. Originally posted by iTim:[..]
    I’m left wondering where that tour voice came from. Few could deny that it was the best shape we’ve heard him in for a long time. These studio recordings are somewhat lacking.
    Agreed. The Colbert performance of With Or Without You in particular was astonishingly good. I was hoping for a taste of that here but the "singing at the kitchen table" comment is pertinent - I don't expect him to bring his Madison Square Garden voice, but maybe something in between where he doesn't sound like he's about to snooze off.
  2. I’ll second the comments that the Colbert performance astonished me - I’m not ashamed to say I teared up after that combo of the powerful spoken word intro from Bono, and then that performance itself. Shockingly emotional and impressive.

    This stuff seems so far from that.

    Again though, to each their own. I’m still here and curious about what Songs of Ascent is going to be, or whatever their next thing is (assuming it comes out and SOS isn’t just a veiled goodbye).

    (Always crossing my fingers for the original version of Mercy and All My Life to show up)
  3. Man, I was the biggest defender of this album concept and I was looking forward to seeing in what interesting ways the songs had been reworked. . . but none of these snippets are winning me over. One was pretty good I guess? Here’s hoping for more interesting arrangements for some of the deep dives I guess.

    “Bono has really matured as a singer, so we wanted to capture that by having him mumble-speak the lyrics to these songs.” - The Edge, probably.
  4. The fly and Desire best versions
  5. I must say they pride is growing on me
  6. Agreed that the Colbert performance was astonishing.

    A controversial thought: Bono might be better served working with other musicians at this point in time (at least some of the time--the way Springsteen works with the E Street Band sometimes and also does a lot of work without them).

    A related controversial thought: It's been a long time since the Edge brought anything astonishing to the table.
  7. How do you think he'd be better served working with other musicians? I mean, he's been doing it during his book tour
  8. Originally posted by dstankie:Agreed that the Colbert performance was astonishing.

    A controversial thought: Bono might be better served working with other musicians at this point in time (at least some of the time--the way Springsteen works with the E Street Band sometimes and also does a lot of work without them).

    A related controversial thought: It's been a long time since the Edge brought anything astonishing to the table.
    Bono and Edge needs Larry and Adam to make their music interesting and special. The more of only B&E the less of the magic.

    But then again: the band I fell in love with in the eighties doesn’t exist anymore. I have no problems with them revisiting and remaking their past. But I don’t enjoy their current path as much as they seem to do.
  9. “Interesting” that the “Essentials” playlist in Apple Music has replaced the original version of Pride with the SOS version.
  10. I think that’s the point, when Bono worked with people outside of the band recently it’s led to better performances or a better performance in the case of With or without you at least which sounds much inferior on the album.
  11. How do you think he'd be better served working with other musicians? I mean, he's been doing it during his book tour


    Exactly. His vocal performances are way better on the book tour than anything I've heard from SOS so far.

    And this: U2 has done their most magical work when others (mainly Eno and Lanois) helped them transcend themselves. U2 as U2 alone has actually always had fairly constrained limits. Think Unforgettable Fire, Joshus Tree, Achtung Baby. Each album was the sound of a band becoming something other/more than they had been or were previously capable of. The music was not just "good," it was astonishing. It was strange at first, then became essential to my life, as if it was something I'd always needed but didn't know until we had it. I know I'm far from alone in that experience, which is what made it all so remarkable: a popular "mainstream" band was making astonishing and necessary music.

    When is the last time U2 astonished you in terms of new material?