Originally posted by badirishcharlie:[..]
You could argue the album is incoherent ( sonically anyway ) so no surprise. I did say I thought reality would land somewhere between those couple of scathing reviews and the 4 star ones.
For now:
There's a bunch of big fat tunes that sound like U2, but that also sound like something fresh and new. Go, Can't stop us now, Greatest show are standout songs. Glorify is delightful. La Reina is growing on me. I quite like Midnight Sunshine - it's pretty good. Mirror Maker reminds me of Fast Cars. Not a bad song. Superficiality is poppy, not sure yet if I like it. World at War OK is the quieter number, the Man and a Woman of CDL. Torn is somewhat at odds with the rest of the album. It's not doing it for me yet.
If we consider the double album, probably their strongest offering since Bomb. No line had 4 stellar songs (first 3, Breathe), the rest not-so-stellar. SOI pretty good, but they tried too hard. I save EBW, Iris, the last 3. SOE not a good album. Lights of home St Peter, SOL, Little things, Landlady are all I still listen to there.
The two EPs have no big singles, but the tunes are pretty strong.