1. Originally posted by badirishcharlie:[..]


    You could argue the album is incoherent ( sonically anyway ) so no surprise. I did say I thought reality would land somewhere between those couple of scathing reviews and the 4 star ones.
    I have been listening to the various songs in random order. Tomorrow I will have a clearer view.

    For now:

    There's a bunch of big fat tunes that sound like U2, but that also sound like something fresh and new. Go, Can't stop us now, Greatest show are standout songs. Glorify is delightful. La Reina is growing on me. I quite like Midnight Sunshine - it's pretty good. Mirror Maker reminds me of Fast Cars. Not a bad song. Superficiality is poppy, not sure yet if I like it. World at War OK is the quieter number, the Man and a Woman of CDL. Torn is somewhat at odds with the rest of the album. It's not doing it for me yet.

    If we consider the double album, probably their strongest offering since Bomb. No line had 4 stellar songs (first 3, Breathe), the rest not-so-stellar. SOI pretty good, but they tried too hard. I save EBW, Iris, the last 3. SOE not a good album. Lights of home St Peter, SOL, Little things, Landlady are all I still listen to there.

    The two EPs have no big singles, but the tunes are pretty strong.
  2. I think they're all at a pretty similar level, one a bit better here, another one there, in the end there are good songs on all of these albums and I'll listen to them a lot throughout my life, it depends on expectations, I just thought the reviews overrated CDL and underrated the last 3 way too much
  3. Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:[..]
    I guess if you take out the length of time Larry wasn’t available it makes more sense. Plus this has to be the most u2 music we got in one year, ever?
    Exactly. And the end result of a finished album usually sounds effortless, but I'm sure a lot of work went into these songs.
  4. Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:[..]
    I guess if you take out the length of time Larry wasn’t available it makes more sense. Plus this has to be the most u2 music we got in one year, ever?


    Yep. But the EP’s seem to have been put together with relative haste and no fanfare. And they are better than the album (not ready to declare that fully yet but that’s where I am heading).

    Time (and excessive amounts of it) is not good for U2 projects.
  5. But no more opinions from me for tonight. It needs time and I am way too distracted by the live performance of GSOE.

    Looking forward to adding the CD to the shelf tomorrow.
  6. Originally posted by germcevoy:But no more opinions from me for tonight. It needs time and I am way too distracted by the live performance of GSOE.

    Looking forward to adding the CD to the shelf tomorrow.
    Yes quite. Enjoy everybody
  7. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:From being negative, Silencio and TGSOE have made me more positive again.
    Well here we go...



    Go (Carnaval de Luz
    Good track, the intro sound of the track should have been through the whole song

    La Reina
    Does nothing, meh track

    Street of Dreams
    One of the their worst track

    The Mirror Maker
    Some interesting elements, but the chours is far to moderna and poppy

    Superficiality
    Awful chours, this sound to much pop-tracks that we found on SOI/SOI
    Way to mainstream modern sound.


    If the World Is at War We Better Not Be


    No, stop using vocal effects please. No acappella

    Silencio
    Great track!

    The Greatest Show on Earth
    One of their best songs latley

    Glorify
    Zara Larsson? No, please...

    Midnight Sunshine
    Crazy Tonights sibling.... Nope. What is this? Chewgummi pop hit?


    Can’t Stop Us Now

    Nothing can stop us now... The music is pretty good, but the verses and chours is too poppy...

    Torn
    A beautiful farewell track


    Please you U2, why? Nine years wating and this was all they could come up with?
    This is overprodcued catchy pop, SOI/SOE are far superior?
    And where is Bonos voice? No high notes, just middle voice all over the place.
    He even avoid using his deep voice , only in TGSOE.

    This isnt U2, this is some kind of modern chewgummi popband pretending to be U2.
    This is to me the worst album ever, HTDAAB feels like a materpeice compared to this album.


    Chewgummi? Are you okay?
  8. La Reina being a meh track is a crazy take lol
  9. Before hearing the album, I thought Rosalia will be a low point but actually it became one of my favorite on the first listen.
  10. It’s a Pop (Rock) album. Some people are gonna have a problem with that.
  11. Exactly, and it's very well done

    It's very good

    Overall, being objective, it's not a 5/5, of course, but it's, at least, a 4.3 /5

    I can't give it a proper rating right now, it's too early.

    But, for U2 at this stage, or for any band at this stage, is great!
    I'm sooooo glad they're still here