1. This EP is a remarkable piece of their music. "The Song for Hal" is a new hallmark, U2's pinnacle. Structurally and emotionally, their best piece, pure musical beauty, with profound personal touch. Very unusual and tender song, with several climaxes, excellent drums and bass and stellar guitar. Prima facie, usual chords, but the structure and the texture of the song makes everything over the top, way beyond ordinary U2 song. The guitar hovers all around, creating incredible groove over time signature, speeding it up a little, slowing it down in miliseconds. There is a very strange dynamics. typical of Egde's style, but upgraded to a complete new level. The Edge said in a recent interview that he studied masters of classical guitar and it can be heard. The chords are layered in a new manner, changes and ornaments are unexpected, everything is new, although it's the good old Edge. Mesmerizing, really. Nothing else really matters, will they tour, what will they play, will they record this or that... With this EP they really nailed it down. And what critics or magazines have to say... It's not important. "The Song for Hal" is above five stars in some review. Even if this is their swan song, it couldn't be stronger and more emotional. Absolute masterpiece. Thanks God, all the bullshit is gone, media, megalomania, politics, pompous statements, losing in charts, trends, production gimmicks, blahblahs, infotainment, adverts, social media, showbiz theatre, all gone... Just the greatest U2 piece of music as a redemption and catharsis. Thanks, guys.
  2. Originally posted by RedSky:More references to ATYCLB - still makes me feel like all this joy and wonder is from the fans who were late to the party

    ATYCLB is an okay album but 2000 onwards is when U2 lost their direction a huge number of times

    Will this new stuff get them back to the top? No - unless the new album is a masterpiece AND it NEEDS to be a masterpiece not just good


    Fully Agree
  3. Originally posted by Jazz:This EP is a remarkable piece of their music. "The Song for Hal" is a new hallmark, U2's pinnacle. Structurally and emotionally, their best piece, pure musical beauty, with profound personal touch. Very unusual and tender song, with several climaxes, excellent drums and bass and stellar guitar. Prima facie, usual chords, but the structure and the texture of the song makes everything over the top, way beyond ordinary U2 song. The guitar hovers all around, creating incredible groove over time signature, speeding it up a little, slowing it down in miliseconds. There is a very strange dynamics. typical of Egde's style, but upgraded to a complete new level. The Edge said in a recent interview that he studied masters of classical guitar and it can be heard. The chords are layered in a new manner, changes and ornaments are unexpected, everything is new, although it's the good old Edge. Mesmerizing, really. Nothing else really matters, will they tour, what will they play, will they record this or that... With this EP they really nailed it down. And what critics or magazines have to say... It's not important. "The Song for Hal" is above five stars in some review. Even if this is their swan song, it couldn't be stronger and more emotional. Absolute masterpiece. Thanks God, all the bullshit is gone, media, megalomania, politics, pompous statements, losing in charts, trends, production gimmicks, blahblahs, infotainment, adverts, social media, showbiz theatre, all gone... Just the greatest U2 piece of music as a redemption and catharsis. Thanks, guys.
    Well put, it feels like a classic already.
  4. "since ATYCLB"

    To be clear my fave albums are: AB, JT, War, TUF, Zooropa, Pop. ATYCLB is prob in the bottom 4 for me. But it was a cohesive album.


    Originally posted by RedSky:More references to ATYCLB - still makes me feel like all this joy and wonder is from the fans who were late to the party

    ATYCLB is an okay album but 2000 onwards is when U2 lost their direction a huge number of times

    Will this new stuff get them back to the top? No - unless the new album is a masterpiece AND it NEEDS to be a masterpiece not just good
  5. Originally posted by Jazz:This EP is a remarkable piece of their music. "The Song for Hal" is a new hallmark, U2's pinnacle. Structurally and emotionally, their best piece, pure musical beauty, with profound personal touch. Very unusual and tender song, with several climaxes, excellent drums and bass and stellar guitar. Prima facie, usual chords, but the structure and the texture of the song makes everything over the top, way beyond ordinary U2 song. The guitar hovers all around, creating incredible groove over time signature, speeding it up a little, slowing it down in miliseconds. There is a very strange dynamics. typical of Egde's style, but upgraded to a complete new level. The Edge said in a recent interview that he studied masters of classical guitar and it can be heard. The chords are layered in a new manner, changes and ornaments are unexpected, everything is new, although it's the good old Edge. Mesmerizing, really. Nothing else really matters, will they tour, what will they play, will they record this or that... With this EP they really nailed it down. And what critics or magazines have to say... It's not important. "The Song for Hal" is above five stars in some review. Even if this is their swan song, it couldn't be stronger and more emotional. Absolute masterpiece. Thanks God, all the bullshit is gone, media, megalomania, politics, pompous statements, losing in charts, trends, production gimmicks, blahblahs, infotainment, adverts, social media, showbiz theatre, all gone... Just the greatest U2 piece of music as a redemption and catharsis. Thanks, guys.
    Love this. 3:40-4:15 is pure bliss
  6. I have mixed feelings on the riff at the end of Coexist...
  7. .
  8. My Ranking of U2 Discography:

    1- Achtung Baby
    2- Joshua Tree
    3- Pride (In The Name of Love) & Bad
    4- Sunday Bloody Sunday, New Year's Day, Two Hearts Beat as One, Surrender, Drowning Man, Seconds & 40
    5- The Unforgettable Fire
    6- Zooropa
    7 - Boy
    8 - R & H (EP): Angel of Harlem, All I Want Is You, Love Rescue Me, Heartland, Desire, Van Diemen's Land, Hawkmoon.
    9 - All That You Can't Leave Behind
    10- How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb
    11- Easter Lily (EP)
    12- Miss Sarajevo & Hold Me, Thrill Me
    13- Pop
    14- Gloria & October
    15- NLOTH

    Honorable mentions:
    Tears of Things
    The Little Things That Give You Away
    Every Breaking Wave
    Song for Someone
    Book of Your Heart
    Landlady
    Moment of Surrender

    Notes:
    War is not there because of Red Light and The Refugee.
    R&H is not there because it doesn't count as an album.
    S.O.S doesn't count.
    SOI and SOE could have been 1 album. So, I'm not counting them.
    October is not good enough.
  9. Originally posted by Jazz:This EP is a remarkable piece of their music. "The Song for Hal" is a new hallmark, U2's pinnacle. Structurally and emotionally, their best piece, pure musical beauty, with profound personal touch. Very unusual and tender song, with several climaxes, excellent drums and bass and stellar guitar. Prima facie, usual chords, but the structure and the texture of the song makes everything over the top, way beyond ordinary U2 song. The guitar hovers all around, creating incredible groove over time signature, speeding it up a little, slowing it down in miliseconds. There is a very strange dynamics. typical of Egde's style, but upgraded to a complete new level. The Edge said in a recent interview that he studied masters of classical guitar and it can be heard. The chords are layered in a new manner, changes and ornaments are unexpected, everything is new, although it's the good old Edge. Mesmerizing, really. Nothing else really matters, will they tour, what will they play, will they record this or that... With this EP they really nailed it down. And what critics or magazines have to say... It's not important. "The Song for Hal" is above five stars in some review. Even if this is their swan song, it couldn't be stronger and more emotional. Absolute masterpiece. Thanks God, all the bullshit is gone, media, megalomania, politics, pompous statements, losing in charts, trends, production gimmicks, blahblahs, infotainment, adverts, social media, showbiz theatre, all gone... Just the greatest U2 piece of music as a redemption and catharsis. Thanks, guys.
    Thank you for sharing these insights.
    You're hitting some very important and true points here:

    These guys are mid-60 and still searching for new ground.
    They could've just keep on playing the hits à la Simple Minds or releasing music from the old blueprints, but no. That's not sufficient.
    Plus, what's indeed more important is that the long-time concern of "being relevant" doesn't matter to them anymore.

    Tbh, I still don't know what to think of this EP, as it's so different indeed.
    My brain just doesn't connect all the dots yet (could be me).
    But you can tell these songs come from another deep and both univeral, yet personal level that's very important to them.
    Not just the typical love/death/friendship themes (SOI) or criticism about the world (DOA), but something deeper.

    Happy to try and dig in during the next weeks/months.
  10. Originally posted by BelgianBono:[..]
    Thank you for sharing these insights.
    You're hitting some very important and true points here:

    These guys are mid-60 and still searching for new ground.
    They could've just keep on playing the hits à la Simple Minds or releasing music from the old blueprints, but no. That's not sufficient.
    Plus, what's indeed more important is that the long-time concern of "being relevant" doesn't matter to them anymore.

    Tbh, I still don't know what to think of this EP, as it's so different indeed.
    My brain just doesn't connect all the dots yet (could be me).
    But you can tell these songs come from another deep and both univeral, yet personal level that's very important to them.
    Not just the typical love/death/friendship themes (SOI) or criticism about the world (DOA), but something deeper.

    Happy to try and dig in during the next weeks/months.
    the personal, the universal, and the eternal
  11. Originally posted by Jazz:This EP is a remarkable piece of their music. "The Song for Hal" is a new hallmark, U2's pinnacle. Structurally and emotionally, their best piece, pure musical beauty, with profound personal touch. Very unusual and tender song, with several climaxes, excellent drums and bass and stellar guitar. Prima facie, usual chords, but the structure and the texture of the song makes everything over the top, way beyond ordinary U2 song. The guitar hovers all around, creating incredible groove over time signature, speeding it up a little, slowing it down in miliseconds. There is a very strange dynamics. typical of Egde's style, but upgraded to a complete new level. The Edge said in a recent interview that he studied masters of classical guitar and it can be heard. The chords are layered in a new manner, changes and ornaments are unexpected, everything is new, although it's the good old Edge. Mesmerizing, really. Nothing else really matters, will they tour, what will they play, will they record this or that... With this EP they really nailed it down. And what critics or magazines have to say... It's not important. "The Song for Hal" is above five stars in some review. Even if this is their swan song, it couldn't be stronger and more emotional. Absolute masterpiece. Thanks God, all the bullshit is gone, media, megalomania, politics, pompous statements, losing in charts, trends, production gimmicks, blahblahs, infotainment, adverts, social media, showbiz theatre, all gone... Just the greatest U2 piece of music as a redemption and catharsis. Thanks, guys.


    Just like that.

    The Song for Hal it’s a masterpiece for my ears.

    I would never expect something like that at their age. I’m shocked

    Together DOA and Easter Lilly are really remarkable. And 5/6 songs that bring me goosebumps. More than happy.