1. By using the word masterpiece to qualify their albums then it has to be their pinnacle of art and craft. Their Magnum Opus. How can albums that tail off so badly like ATYCLB be viewed as that. As for the 2 EP's for me good solid works from the band.
  2. Arguably U2 had only three true masterpieces to its name: War. TJT. Achtung Baby. One could argue that albums containing songs as bad as Elvis Presley and America (TUF), Love Rescue Me (R&H), Some Days Are Better Than Others (Zooropa), Miami (Pop), Elevation (ATYCLB), All Because Of You (HTDAAB), Get On Your Boots (NLOTH) can never be called masterpieces. Or can they. To me all those are just very (or even very very) good albums and it’s more than good enough most of the times. You can only create so many masterpieces in a lifetime.
  3. Originally posted by Bonu:Arguably U2 had only three true masterpieces to its name: War. TJT. Achtung Baby. One could argue that albums containing such bad songs as Elvis Presley and America (TUF), Love Rescue Me (R&H), Some Days Are Better Than Others (Zooropa), Miami (Pop), Wild Honey (ATYCLB), All Because Of You (HTDAAB), Get On Your Boots (NLOTH) can never be called masterpieces. Or can they. To me all those are just very (or even very very) good albums and it’s more than good enough most of the times. You can only create so many masterpieces in a lifetime.
    War a masterpiece with Red Light on it doesn't make sense with the rest of your comment
  4. In theory even TJT with Trip Through Your Wires and AB with So Cruel and Tryin' to Throw Your Arms Around the World wouldn’t make the grade. Yet somehow they do, just as War does. Magic. Or perhaps those songs aren’t as bad as Miami and perfectly fit the albums that they are placed on. However you want to answer this, your comment makes no sense if you only question War, and not the other two albums.
  5. I don’t think war is a masterpiece because of red light and the refugee. Tryin, so cruel and trip are much better songs I’d argue. Red light and refugee would be amongst my bottom 20 album songs, Red light probably bottom 10. I don’t think Grace or wild honey are as bad as some people say though which is why I’ve got ATYCLB in the masterpiece category but maybe there’s enough people out there arguing against those songs it can’t really be considered a masterpiece. I wouldn’t strongly argue against the idea that JT and AB are their only albums in that category. Maybe there’s a category for ‘great’ being just below masterpiece.
  6. Originally posted by tuf392664:I don’t think war is a masterpiece because of red light and the refugee. Tryin, so cruel and trip are much better songs I’d argue. Red light and refugee would be amongst my bottom 20 album songs, Red light probably bottom 10. I don’t think Grace or wild honey are as bad as some people say though which is why I’ve got ATYCLB in the masterpiece category but maybe there’s enough people out there arguing against those songs it can’t really be considered a masterpiece. I wouldn’t strongly argue against the idea that JT and AB are their only albums in that category. Maybe there’s a category for ‘great’ being just below masterpiece.
    It all subjective. I personally think ATYCLB is one of their worst albums. Mostly Uninteresting musically with the exception of some songs (kite is right up there with their best work ) a very stripped back sound. Which is what they where going for and for me it doesn't hold up to multiple listens because of that. The unforgettable Fire is an album that should be considered in their top tier.. it's highs are the best of any U2 albums and it's lows ( I enjoy it all) are experimental sketches which I feel fits what they where going for.
  7. It's not ALL subjective.

    There are objective reasons why certain works of art are rated more highly than others. These include originality, realization of expression, cultural impact, appreciation across time/context, etc.

    And it is totally possible to not really like/appreciate something subjectively, while still recognizing its importance. For instance, I prefer older (that is, newer), more mature Bob Dylan to his 60s records, but only an idiot would argue that Blonde on Blonde, for example, is NOT a masterpiece.

    The consensus that JT and AB are masterpieces is pretty soundly based. The fact that there are arguments to be made for and against other albums without anything approaching consensus suggests something about these other albums' potential shortcomings.
  8. Originally posted by dstankie:It's not ALL subjective.

    There are objective reasons why certain works of art are rated more highly than others. These include originality, realization of expression, cultural impact, appreciation across time/context, etc.

    And it is totally possible to not really like/appreciate something subjectively, while still recognizing its importance. For instance, I prefer older (that is, newer), more mature Bob Dylan to his 60s records, but only an idiot would argue that Blonde on Blonde, for example, is NOT a masterpiece.

    The consensus that JT and AB are masterpieces is pretty soundly based. The fact that there are arguments to be made for and against other albums without anything approaching consensus suggests something about these other albums' potential shortcomings.
    I think your last sentence is a good way of summing it up actually and why I can accept the likes of Zooropa, all that you can’t leave behind and Easter Lily aren’t put in the masterpiece category.
  9. After 3 weeks of Easter Lily, I already got bored of it, they can release the album already
  10. I still revisit Coesxist. Everything else became a little disposable. Tears of THings and Coesxist are legit.
  11. I'm still listening to the whole EP on repeat - I love it
  12. 3 weeks you’ll be bored of that too

    We’re essentially getting two albums this year. Could be the last two ever. Seems crazy to be so dismissive.