1. Originally posted by pleasegone:Songs of Experience EP:
    I have Zero Zero Zero love for Auto Tune Is All We Have Left....awful example of them pandering to young people. At the time they probably thought Auto Tune was some exciting new thing....not a way for great looking young people who can't sing to hide their voice.
    ...


    How is that song in any way pandering to young people?
    How is that song in any way attractive to young people?
    Can they dance to it? Can they jump to it? Can they sing it? Are the lyrics easy and uplifting like it's EDM?


    If anything, that song is a good example on how to use auto-tune correctly in a creative way.

    Just because some "singers" hide their deficiencies with autotune and those artists play latin/hip hop music, which is popular with young crowds, doesn't mean that anybody using a tool like that is "pandering" to those people.
  2. Originally posted by pleasegone:
    Aww man, couldn't disagree with you more...but that's ok....I have Zero Zero Zero love for Auto Tune Is All We Have Left....awful example of them pandering to young people. At the time they probably thought Auto Tune was some exciting new thing....not a way for great looking young people who can't sing to hide their voice.
    ...


    Pretty sure they are using a vocoder on Bono’s voice there and not autotune. Yes it’s a highly altered vocal but to hear Bono talk of wanting it to be a sci-fi futuristic Sinatra sound, sounds like it was his concept to begin with. And personally it’s one of my favourite songs from that album…
  3. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:[..]


    Pretty sure they are using a vocoder on Bono’s voice there and not autotune. Yes it’s a highly altered vocal but to hear Bono talk of wanting it to be a sci-fi futuristic Sinatra sound, sounds like it was his concept to begin with. And personally it’s one of my favourite songs from that album…
    Agreed!
  4. ‘Auto tune’ as a tool and auto tune as a necessity are a very different thing. There can be no doubt that Bono has used the tools as a vocal effect rather than as a vocal aid.
  5. It could be possible that they used it just because that is a familiar sound to youngish people now. It is just so common.
  6. Originally posted by pepokiss:[..]


    How is that song in any way pandering to young people?
    How is that song in any way attractive to young people?
    Can they dance to it? Can they jump to it? Can they sing it? Are the lyrics easy and uplifting like it's EDM?


    If anything, that song is a good example on how to use auto-tune correctly in a creative way.

    Just because some "singers" hide their deficiencies with autotune and those artists play latin/hip hop music, which is popular with young crowds, doesn't mean that anybody using a tool like that is "pandering" to those people.
    This
  7. Was the change to Bono's voice on Zoo Station or The Fly to pander to a younger generation? No, it just suited the songs that way. Love Is All We Have Left works with the auto tune effect, it was used to enhance and create a mood, not because Bono's own voice couldn't manage it.
  8. I love Love Is All We Have left. Always envisaged him opening a show with it, just a spotlight on him - that would've been great! 🍻
  9. 'Love is all we have left' is sublime. Love Bono's delivery and lyrics on it. Definitely my favorite on a brilliant album.

    I'm in a minority that prefer SOE over SOI:

    Songs of Innocence ~368 million streams
    Songs of Experience ~271 million streams.
  10. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    'Love is all we have left' is sublime. Love Bono's delivery and lyrics on it. Definitely my favorite on a brilliant album.

    I'm in a minority that prefer SOE over SOI:

    Songs of Innocence ~368 million streams
    Songs of Experience ~271 million streams.
    Innocence had four additional years to get there.

    I prefer SOE over SOI as well. I liked the back half of SOI, but the front half didn't do much for me. Was happier with the bonus tracks on SOI.
  11. Originally posted by miryclay:It could be possible that they used it just because that is a familiar sound to youngish people now. It is just so common.
    Exactly!!! It's simply pandering to a younger audience hoping for that relevance they are hoping for. It's cringe worthy due it not sounding creative, but sounding like the Grandpas going to a club wearing what the 21 year olds wear.
  12. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:Innocence had four additional years to get there.

    I prefer SOE over SOI as well. I liked the back half of SOI, but the front half didn't do much for me. Was happier with the bonus tracks on SOI.


    Forgot about the 4 year gap.

    SOI didn't start to click for me until the Paris DVD so it might just be the production work by Tedder Mouse.