1. I’ve been listening to U2 since 1987. Everything from the early stuff up to No Line on the Horizon in 2009, I was all in. After that, for me, it turned into utter shite. Nothing landed, nothing I wanted to replay. I was actually getting angry and frustrated with the direction they took with SOI, SOE and SOS. I genuinely dislike it, don’t listen to it at all. It doesn’t exist for me. What it did do though is make me appreciate Pop, ATYCLB and HTDAAB even more.

    But Easter Lily… this is the first time since NLOTH that I can actually put something on freakin’ repeat again. Ash was a good surprise, but Lily is bang on for me, especially considering I thought they were done for me forever.

    And the main reason is simple, it finally sounds like freaking U2 again.

    Edge’s guitar is back to what we know from him. That sound that makes U2, not buried or messed with, just open and atmospheric. Adam is properly back on bass, not that he was ever gone, but it just works again when everything around him clicks. He’s locking everything in, giving it weight. Larry sounds like he’s actually enjoying himself again, there’s energy in the drumming, movement, not just keeping time. It feels alive. I always had the feeling he wasn’t happy with the direction before, and this just sounds like a completely different band compared to SOI, SOE and SOS.

    Bono, his voice has been weak for a while, but here he sounds more like Bono again. Not perfect, but more honest, more real, like he actually means what he’s singing instead of just performing it.

    So yeah, I’m actually chuffed, because for about 17 years there was nothing from U2 that I enjoyed. That connection was gone. And now it’s back, maybe not the same as before, but close enough to remind me why I loved them in the first place.

    F*ck them for pulling it off. LOL.

    PS: Stuck Ash and Lily into a Spotify playlist, now I have a 12 track cracking new U2 album !! 😎
  2. cool !
  3. Thanks for sharing! The 'F' bomb is what this form needed!
  4. Thanks haha. This is how it feels man. I felt defeated with them. I genuinely had decided that live tours was over for me. And then they come with this. I am going !!!!
  5. Great report, glad the new songs made you appreciate the band's new material again, but I still find it weird (and I've seen many others saying the same) regarding SOI and SOE, I can't consider both works that bad, there are songs from both albums that if placed in these new EPs would be considered among the best, maybe SOE is the most disappointing, but it also has great songs. I can't see such an absurd change in direction in these new EPs that would make so many people like the band again just now
  6. Originally posted by hedyzera:Great report, glad the new songs made you appreciate the band's new material again, but I still find it weird (and I've seen many others saying the same) regarding SOI and SOE, I can't consider both works that bad, there are songs from both albums that if placed in these new EPs would be considered among the best, maybe SOE is the most disappointing, but it also has great songs. I can't see such an absurd change in direction in these new EPs that would make so many people like the band again just now
    Yeah I get your point, there are some good songs across those 3 albums.

    But that’s not really what I’m getting at. For me it didn’t feel like U2 at all, especially with Edge barely present on some tracks.

    These new EPs just sound like the band again, that’s why it clicks. Funny enough Spotify extended the Ash/Lily queue with the ZooTV Dublin 1993 EP, so even Spotify agrees with my take 😉

    And as you say I’m not the only one hearing it that way, but if it works for you then fair enough, we just hear it differently.
  7. Amen brother! This is it, exactly. It's U2 being U2 again. And it feels amazing!
  8. Nice write up but seems a bit odd given this EP is still largely in the " Songs Of " sound mode
  9. Not about whether those albums had a few good "U2 sounding" songs, most of them never felt like U2 to me. These EPs do, that’s why they’re on repeat. And they work as a whole.

    SOI, the first 5 songs are decent, EBW is definitely a song I love, but I cannot listen to an album on the premise of 1 cracker, 4 OK songs and 6 stinkers.

    And SOS is a rehash album that should have never been made. It’s U2 making poor covers of U2 songs, it’s blasphemy.

    SOE is a bit better than SOI but still not good enough to put it on repeat.

    Easter Lily is U2 as they were. Atmospheric, thumping, rhythmic, all of them peaking more than they did in 17 years.

    Can’t argue on taste though, so I guess no one is right or wrong here 🙂
  10. Anyway, not trying to derail into SOI/SOE debates. Main point is Easter Lily sounds like U2 again and that’s why it’s clicking for me.
  11. I was thinking this too. But now I think that's just how U2 sounds nowadays.
  12. Originally posted by poncke:I’ve been listening to U2 since 1987. Everything from the early stuff up to No Line on the Horizon in 2009, I was all in. After that, for me, it turned into utter shite. Nothing landed, nothing I wanted to replay. I was actually getting angry and frustrated with the direction they took with SOI, SOE and SOS. I genuinely dislike it, don’t listen to it at all. It doesn’t exist for me. What it did do though is make me appreciate Pop, ATYCLB and HTDAAB even more.

    But Easter Lily… this is the first time since NLOTH that I can actually put something on freakin’ repeat again. Ash was a good surprise, but Lily is bang on for me, especially considering I thought they were done for me forever.

    And the main reason is simple, it finally sounds like freaking U2 again.

    Edge’s guitar is back to what we know from him. That sound that makes U2, not buried or messed with, just open and atmospheric. Adam is properly back on bass, not that he was ever gone, but it just works again when everything around him clicks. He’s locking everything in, giving it weight. Larry sounds like he’s actually enjoying himself again, there’s energy in the drumming, movement, not just keeping time. It feels alive. I always had the feeling he wasn’t happy with the direction before, and this just sounds like a completely different band compared to SOI, SOE and SOS.

    Bono, his voice has been weak for a while, but here he sounds more like Bono again. Not perfect, but more honest, more real, like he actually means what he’s singing instead of just performing it.

    So yeah, I’m actually chuffed, because for about 17 years there was nothing from U2 that I enjoyed. That connection was gone. And now it’s back, maybe not the same as before, but close enough to remind me why I loved them in the first place.

    F*ck them for pulling it off. LOL.

    PS: Stuck Ash and Lily into a Spotify playlist, now I have a 12 track cracking new U2 album !! 😎
    BIBLICAL WORDS