1. Blasphemy?

    U2 isn't your little bitch obligated to make the same damn record you liked in the 80s ad nauseam.

    Nothing good in 17 years?

    Originally posted by poncke:[..]
    Not about whether those albums had a few good "U2 sounding" songs, most of them never felt like U2 to me. These EPs do, that’s why they’re on repeat. And they work as a whole.

    SOI, the first 5 songs are decent, EBW is definitely a song I love, but I cannot listen to an album on the premise of 1 cracker, 4 OK songs and 6 stinkers.

    And SOS is a rehash album that should have never been made. It’s U2 making poor covers of U2 songs, it’s blasphemy.

    SOE is a bit better than SOI but still not good enough to put it on repeat.

    Easter Lily is U2 as they were. Atmospheric, thumping, rhythmic, all of them peaking more than they did in 17 years.

    Can’t argue on taste though, so I guess no one is right or wrong here 🙂
  2. 'Pulled it off' - nah, but it's good but not great

    It's okay - but it's not going to shake the foundations of their greatest work

    Happy for you - but for me they need to do better
  3. Originally posted by RedSky:'Pulled it off' - nah, but it's good but not great

    It's okay - but it's not going to shake the foundations of their greatest work

    Happy for you - but for me they need to do better
    They'll "pull it off" with the Album
  4. Originally posted by spfletty:Blasphemy?

    U2 isn't your little bitch obligated to make the same damn record you liked in the 80s ad nauseam.

    Nothing good in 17 years?

    [..]
    Blasphemy for me, yeah. Doesn’t mean they owe me anything.

    And I’m not asking for the 80s again, just for them to sound like U2. For me they didn’t for a long time. These EPs do, that’s the difference.

    If you’ve enjoyed the last 17 years, fair play. I didn’t.
  5. Originally posted by RedSky:'Pulled it off' - nah, but it's good but not great

    It's okay - but it's not going to shake the foundations of their greatest work

    Happy for you - but for me they need to do better
    It is fucking great, but hey, can't argue about taste. Just like the other dude who thinks SOE SOI SOS is good.
  6. Originally posted by poncke:[..]
    Blasphemy for me, yeah. Doesn’t mean they owe me anything.

    And I’m not asking for the 80s again, just for them to sound like U2. For me they didn’t for a long time. These EPs do, that’s the difference.

    If you’ve enjoyed the last 17 years, fair play. I didn’t.
    believe it would be so boring to hear the same songs everytime, tells you the fan who is tired of the “beautiful day” songs and hates SOE