1. Coldplay copied U2, not the other way around—here is the actual history
    ​I keep seeing people claim that U2 is copying Coldplay, but the timeline and music history say the exact opposite.
    ​The Timeline: U2 formed in 1976 and pioneered the delay-heavy, atmospheric stadium-rock sound in the 1980s (The Joshua Tree) and 1990s (Achtung Baby). Coldplay didn't even form until 1996.
    ​Coldplay Admits It: Chris Martin has repeatedly called U2 one of Coldplay's primary inspirations. He’s explicitly stated in multiple interviews that without U2, Coldplay wouldn’t exist as a band.
    ​The Brian Eno Connection: Legendary producer Brian Eno shaped U2’s signature sound on Unforgettable Fire and The Joshua Tree. Years later, Coldplay hired Brian Eno for Viva La Vida specifically to help them tap into that same experimental, widescreen sound.
    ​Where the Confusion Happens: Both bands eventually pivoted into huge, pop-leaning arena anthems in the late 2000s and 2010s. If someone only started listening to music recently, U2’s later pop-rock tracks might sound like Coldplay—but Coldplay was just following a blueprint U2 wrote decades earlier.
  2. My wife loves it. Added to the car playlist straightaway. That means it’s ‘popular good’.
  3. It's even worse than i expected. It’s an insult to my trash can to throw it in there....
  4. And yet this could be Coldplay. Just imagine Chris Martin's voice instead of Bono's.

    Just because Coldplay was influenced by U2 does not mean that U2 has not been subsequently influenced by the pop-drivel-rock of Coldplay.
  5. Originally posted by MircaleDrug:Coldplay copied U2, not the other way around—here is the actual history
    ​I keep seeing people claim that U2 is copying Coldplay, but the timeline and music history say the exact opposite.
    ​The Timeline: U2 formed in 1976 and pioneered the delay-heavy, atmospheric stadium-rock sound in the 1980s (The Joshua Tree) and 1990s (Achtung Baby). Coldplay didn't even form until 1996.
    ​Coldplay Admits It: Chris Martin has repeatedly called U2 one of Coldplay's primary inspirations. He’s explicitly stated in multiple interviews that without U2, Coldplay wouldn’t exist as a band.
    ​The Brian Eno Connection: Legendary producer Brian Eno shaped U2’s signature sound on Unforgettable Fire and The Joshua Tree. Years later, Coldplay hired Brian Eno for Viva La Vida specifically to help them tap into that same experimental, widescreen sound.
    ​Where the Confusion Happens: Both bands eventually pivoted into huge, pop-leaning arena anthems in the late 2000s and 2010s. If someone only started listening to music recently, U2’s later pop-rock tracks might sound like Coldplay—but Coldplay was just following a blueprint U2 wrote decades earlier.
    I think similar producers with bands that sound similar will ultimately lead to comparisons. Coldplay in recent years have gone down the dance/EDM route a lot, give U2 that treatment to their sound and it gets all very similar.

    Of course U2 are the originals, Coldplay and many others have lifted ideas or taken inspiration from them. Just as you can hear early U2 in bands like Joy Division who they also borrowed from. And as much as seminal Achtung Baby is, listen to other music around that time like Jesus Jones, etc.

    Every artist is a cannibal.
  6. Originally posted by popmarter:Is this an emergency release due to the "mixed" reception for SOD? , the band could easily veto any song with their involvement that interfered with the Album release so kinda strange this is been released so soon after SOD.


    No.
  7. Is it just me or is the main guitar break similar to the solo on Miracle Drug?
  8. sjonge wat een treurige comment.. de afgelopen dagen heb je de track alleen maar kunnen afzeiken...

  9. Originally posted by dstankie:I'm confused. Why are people talking about this as a U2 song/single?

    Isn't Martin Garrix the principle maker here? Even if it is a true collaboration, wouldn't this be, at most, something like the work they did with Eno on Passengers?

    I'm all for as many collaborations as they want to do/as much music as possible, but let's try to keep some clarity about the artists/composers/writers.


    It’s being released as a single by Martin Garrix and U2. (Not Martin Garrix featuring U2, which would suggest that it predominantly was a Martin Garrix track.) It will appear as U2’s most recent release on streaming services. Likewise it will will appear the same when viewing Garrix’s discography, It’s a collaboration between the two acts.

    Passengers appears under the "Appears on" section. Which is where this track would have appeared as well if they'd credited U2 as a featuring artist. But where U2 are credited as a primary artist it gets sorted with their own discography.
  10. Originally posted by MircaleDrug:Coldplay copied U2, not the other way around—here is the actual history
    ​I keep seeing people claim that U2 is copying Coldplay, but the timeline and music history say the exact opposite.
    ​The Timeline: U2 formed in 1976 and pioneered the delay-heavy, atmospheric stadium-rock sound in the 1980s (The Joshua Tree) and 1990s (Achtung Baby). Coldplay didn't even form until 1996.
    ​Coldplay Admits It: Chris Martin has repeatedly called U2 one of Coldplay's primary inspirations. He’s explicitly stated in multiple interviews that without U2, Coldplay wouldn’t exist as a band.
    ​The Brian Eno Connection: Legendary producer Brian Eno shaped U2’s signature sound on Unforgettable Fire and The Joshua Tree. Years later, Coldplay hired Brian Eno for Viva La Vida specifically to help them tap into that same experimental, widescreen sound.
    ​Where the Confusion Happens: Both bands eventually pivoted into huge, pop-leaning arena anthems in the late 2000s and 2010s. If someone only started listening to music recently, U2’s later pop-rock tracks might sound like Coldplay—but Coldplay was just following a blueprint U2 wrote decades earlier.
    Are we now generating posts in Chat GPT?
  11. Since when is a messenger an AI
  12. Originally posted by dstankie:And yet this could be Coldplay. Just imagine Chris Martin's voice instead of Bono's.

    Just because Coldplay was influenced by U2 does not mean that U2 has not been subsequently influenced by the pop-drivel-rock of Coldplay.
    I hear that especially in the chorus. I don’t hate this song but I can’t shake that late-era Coldplay feeling.