Originally posted by thalloween:Still can’t understand the hype over this version.. The original 2004 one that we’ve got is just unfinished and unmixed (obviously, I know it’s a leak). However, LMITW just sounds better to me, it has Bono’s mature voice and the ‘04 one, the song is mixed and finished. What am I missing? I would like to understand what’s the hype for this Mercy about
I never got the hype of it either. Each to their own but it just meandered, I prefer LMITW.
Originally posted by tchezao:[..]
It's impossible for you to say you rather this mix than the original or even the 360 mix.
The release version has multiple cuts that makes the song not work at all.
The original version still has an unfinished and plain text, especially in the choruses and latter verses. The '24 version imo is finished and polished, to me it makes much more sense. Still can't understand the hype however for this '04 version!
The 2004 version is U2/Bono letting go and finding their way into some beautiful open territory. Though a bit messy, there is an integrity of ecstasy (something like that found on the Unforgettable Fire and in lots of great jazz albums). I still find it more powerful than maybe anything else they've released since (including HTDAAB).
The 2025 version is the opposite: it tries to enforce control and tries to shape too much, thereby blunting the ecstatic joy of the original and muddling the themes and emotional content of the lyrics. It's the bane of much of their output over the last couple decades: you can feel the effort with which it was put together without finding the spirit of true inspiration that brings unity to any work of great art.