FEA
Active topics
  1. Voted for SOE, but verry close call
  3. Both great but Experience edges it for me
  4. This is tough..
    SOI wins for me
  5. Songs of Experience.....as they rediscovered 'songs' after a long time.
    SOI sounded like demos to me, too forced, too raw, no polish.
    SOE sounds effortless. Little Things & Love is Bigger are right up there for me.

    Tour wise, SOE though, it was rawer, less self indulgent, had peaks and builds. This tour is too static and too much about 'the story' for my tastes. Lacks any punch.
  6. SoE and it’s not close in my book
  7. Yeah, that goes without saying. We can't always put "In my opinion..." to every post.
  8. Can't understand the love for SOE on this forum. Just an average U2 record.
  9. I’d agree. I always think there was one good album between SOI and SOE. A lot of filler stuff on both.
  10. No way is there any fillers on SOE... I class songs like One Step Closer, Man and a Woman, Stand Up Comedy, White as Snow, etc as fillers and nothing that poor on SOE.
  11. Almost half of SOE is a filler.............