1. They used to focus group their stuff to death before they released it.

    Desire doesn't seem to show any signs of external review.

    Or maybe people close to them are afraid to tell them when they're no good now. Because everyone else treats them like musical geniuses. Ahimsa, Ordinary Love, Your song saved my life, I believe in father christmas, We are the people, etc - the wreckage is piling up.
  2. Some of them sound terrible. Can't wait to see the 2.0 or worse Pitchfork review.
  3. I have to agree with a few others that desire sounds dreadful. Get out of your own way and two hearts beat as one don’t fill me with confidence from the brief bits in the audiobook. Some others like invisible, city of blinding lights and until the end of the word fill me with more hope though. I’m enjoying Pride a little more today too, probably won’t be one I’ll end up picking out in isolation from the album but decent enough.
  4. Originally posted by j1167198:[..]
    They used to focus group their stuff to death before they released it.

    Desire doesn't seem to show any signs of external review.

    Or maybe people close to them are afraid to tell them when they're no good now. Because everyone else treats them like musical geniuses. Ahimsa, Ordinary Love, Your song saved my life, I believe in father christmas, We are the people, etc - the wreckage is piling up.
    I simply meant it’s difficult to tell whether some of these are legit or online pisstakes. I do jest ever so slightly of course but some of these sound bizarre and others sound horrific.

    I’ll have to wait until I hear them via a trusted source.

  5. Some people have actually commented on it on YouTube already believing it’s legit . Anyone who even thinks there’s a 1% chance this is legit can’t be taken seriously when criticising or praising any of the bands work.
  6. just thinking..., wouldn't it be great if al the versions we hear up until now turn out to be NOT the definitive SOS album versions, but just leaked to confuse us.....

    and than, when it's finaly march 17th, U2 blow us all out of the water with at least 30 great, completly new full band versions? would LOVE that!
  7. Originally posted by u2joost:just thinking..., wouldn't it be great if al the versions we hear up until now turn out to be NOT the definitive SOS album versions, but just leaked to confuse us.....

    and than, when it's finaly march 17th, U2 blow us all out of the water with at least 30 great, completly new full band versions? would LOVE that!
    I don't think that will happen but I am hoping for some surprises in the songs like the way the end of the new Pride comes together.
  8. Originally posted by kris_smith87:It is wild to me how terribly terribly negative this forum has been since for sure the release of Songs Of Experience and a little before that.

    Negative? As I have said there are 3 types of people in this world:

    Type 1: Everything has to be wonderful, glass full, or glass overflowing. I broke my leg, but life is perfect! Bono used Auto Tune on Love Is All We Have Left...how profound! He is using cutting edge technology and leading the way to influencing new musicians in the future!

    Type 2: Everything Is Awful, I have a rain cloud over me all the time, and that's who I am! (SOE is trash, even Little Things is terrible!)( my reality: I happen to like SOE, and Little Things is a classic!)

    Type 3: Honest people. As much as I have bitched about SOS being a dumb over calculated move(Most band's lowest selling album is the covers album, or the re-recordings of old songs...Sting, Bon Jovi, etc.), I hope I at least like it...but I will be honest in my opinion. I find most on this great fan site to be in this category...but I think we all can meander in Type 1 or Type 2 from time to time...we're all human! If you think something is garbage, say it with conviction. If you love something...same thing...Try to be a Type 3!

    My honest opinion: Pride is pretty bad, I am expecting the worst from this album, but I will buy the 4CD version, and hope I can find something to love or at least appreciate...but with seemingly little Adam and Larry inovolvement...ha new word, I am not expecting much. It sounds like they want to hang out with Axl Rose and get advice on how to delay an album. But, as others have pointed out...SOS is something I would love a new Stevie Wonder album...but he's not releasing anything. Same for Billy Joel. A shit U2 album is better than nothing. I understand the concept of 4 10 song cds...but the key part of that word is CON. Just put the 20 Bono & Edge songs on 1 disc, and the 20 Adam & Larry songs on another. This thing is not going to profit very much. Don't milk your fans for paying more. You may as well make it 40 discs with one song each if that is the focus. It seems U2 is just Bono and Edge these days, and the "Other Guys" seem like hired hands. Sad...but that's what it looks like. I like the audio book more than I thought I would, but found the music to sound more like what Teddy Bear Tedder would do with the old songs.

    I'm tired of people thinking everyone is being negative. Sure nobody here has all 40 songs, but websites like this are for opinions..positive, negative, and in between. I'm also tired of hearing how this likely wretched piece of garbage project will tarnish their legacy. Really? They could make five shit albums in a row(which would take 100 years or so)...and they already have a great legacy. Nothing will do that. War, TUF, Joshua, Rattle, Achtung is a legacy that will never be taken from them. Even if they do Auto Tune again with that sometimes good producer Set The Bar Low.
  9. by now, listening to some leaks, nothing is sounding as bad as some are saying, there are interesting things... I've always found most of the criticism here on this forum to be exaggerated.
  10. What are they saying over at Interference?