1. Originally posted by marik:[..]
    Within 10sec of listening to this for the first time, I can assure you it's Edge. Kinda surprised its even a question


    Definitely doesn't sound like Bono
  2. Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:Not one of these versions I’ve heard so far is anywhere near the quality of the original. There’s no reason for them to exist to my ears. Looking forward to a new album. Hopefully.

    I hear you. I’m not expecting any of them to be “improvements” at all (other than maybe a couple more obscure ones). Just kind of a cool “bonus” from the band before a new album. I play the guitar - and piano, badly - and always think it’s fun to mess around with different keys and arrangements of songs. So for me it will be just an enjoyable listen, nothing more or less.

    The audiobook snippets got me curious already and looking forward to something that’s more than just a compilation of already existing material, anyway.
  3. Gotta be honest (and I say this realizing I don’t spend a whole lot of time here, or even following/listening to U2 much these days) - the new version of Pride - and the few clips I listened to from a previous page in this thread - sound incredibly awful lol. This project screams “we’re old as fuck now” instead of “wow these songs in a new light are so interesting and great”.

    Way to poop all over an incredible back catalogue, with recordings that only demonstrate how far away they are from the exciting and groundbreaking musicians they once were. It reminds me of those singles they released where one side was a JT single, and the other side was the same song but from a live performance from the JT30 tour. Going from one version to the other was like….why’d they think this was a good idea?

    Should’ve just done a new record with this acoustic vibe if that’s what they want to do right now. This is just kind of embarrassing.

    Absolutely loved Bono’s book though 🙂

    EDIT: it’s laughable to me that this thing has a super deluxe set haha.
  4. The way this is being promoted is another instance of U2 hubris (don't know if that's their fault or management's).

    It seems to me to be on par with the following missteps:

    Rattle and Hum (the movie) was a flop. Not that it's bad, just that it is for fans and couldn't sustain the wide release it got. Lots and lots of backlash from music fans and critics alike. Thankfully, they came back with the greatest album of all time a couple years later.

    Freaking Spiderman. Bad songs for a bad production. Why?

    The Songs of Innocence release debacle. It destroyed what little was left of U2's cache as a significant band of the 21st century (no one would deny they were a significant band of the 80s and 90s).

    And now this. Who on God's green earth needs such bland versions of great songs?

    At most, this should be a fan club release.

    I'm honestly worried that this new project is not just a nail in the coffin but the coffin itself.
  5. It is wild to me how terribly terribly negative this forum has been since for sure the release of Songs Of Experience and a little before that.
  6. Originally posted by dstankie:The way this is being promoted is another instance of U2 hubris (don't know if that's their fault or management's).

    It seems to me to be on par with the following missteps:

    Rattle and Hum (the movie) was a flop. Not that it's bad, just that it is for fans and couldn't sustain the wide release it got. Lots and lots of backlash from music fans and critics alike. Thankfully, they came back with the greatest album of all time a couple years later.

    Freaking Spiderman. Bad songs for a bad production. Why?

    The Songs of Innocence release debacle. It destroyed what little was left of U2's cache as a significant band of the 21st century (no one would deny they were a significant band of the 80s and 90s).

    And now this. Who on God's green earth needs such bland versions of great songs?

    At most, this should be a fan club release.

    I'm honestly worried that this new project is not just a nail in the coffin but the coffin itself.
    IMHO they made it for teenage generation fans. I spoke with older fans 40+ and all said the same ,,U2's ,,new direction,, is a total crap,,. I hope new album will be more AB-HTDAAB era.
  7. I feel like at this point the type of album that would gain the band most praise is probably the type of album that they’d least like to make. Some sort of heavy, dark album that seems a million miles away from the bands claim that love is bigger than anything. I just don’t think the band are in the right place to make the album they need to make to get the praise probably all of us on here want them to get. That doesn’t mean I personally don’t love the bands more recent work, I do, and I’m confident I’ll enjoy the next album and enjoy listening to songs of surrender at least to some extent but for the band to really get even the slightest bit of praise from a non fan it’s going to need to take something bold but not too clever, too experimental I don’t think will go down well, it needs to be just purely heavy, try and appeal to proper rock lovers and get far away as possible from the chart sound who’s listeners are never going to come round to u2.
  8. I like Pride. I like the other songs I heard so far and I can’t wait to hear the other songs.

    For me, NLOTH, SOI and SOE are the same “sound”. And finally they are trying a different direction once more. In the 90’s the experiment was more and more and more. Now the experiment is less. We shall see over time where that experiment will bring them.

    Last wednesday when they released Pride I was walking in a mall. While listening it gave me goosebumps. The respect for the past by integrating Bono’s original recording, but still make a complete new song.

    The next chapter for me is how these songs will survive on the stage. Based on the performance in The Ambassador they will. Although that setting was really different than arenas or stadiums. We will see…
  9. I too am surprised at how negative some of the reactions are. I don’t know, I found the JT17 tour way more disappointing in terms of rehashing the past and any AB Vegas shows even more so.

    I’m not super excited about this but kind of look at it as an album of B-sides, or as I’ve said before the Graduate School to the AB Kindergarten. I also don’t think it says much or anything at all about their future direction either…but only time will tell.
  10. Lots of newbies on U2start these days....Just Sayin'