Originally posted by felix2:What I don't understand about it is how it has been revealed that the old/rearranged songs will sound different than the original songs. How can you explain the time difference from 2019 to 2022, that these songs will sound really different if they are played live? At the latest for the promo for 40 songs and in the Sphere in Las Vegas 2023. We're talking about almost 4 years.
Miryclay gave a great answer to this:
Some things to consider with reworking.
1)key changes and instrumentation changes are possible. See EBW
2)playing live over time allow the songs to go in unexpected directions
3)producers can be very influential to a final track. A 'defeated' idea of the past could be explored or re-born
4)band infighting could be consequential. See Mercy
And I will add this from my own experiences:
As a songwriter, I can write one up, and think THIS IS THE SONG, AND THIS IS HOW IT IS PERFORMED...then I'll be sitting around doing nothing, thinking about a particular composition of mine, and think...What if I sang this a little faster? What if I changed the bass line? What if I made it a ballad sounding song? What if I eliminated most of the guitar and made the basis of the song electric keyboards? Or Acoustic Piano? I know the temptation is to think that the SOE songs are not that old, what really could change?
The answer: A lot. I just don't think that U2 are capable of pulling this off for 10 songs. For 40 songs? No. If they do, I'll be happy and shocked. Again, as a songwriter, I can change anything the way I want to. Does that mean it will be any good? No, not at all.
The quality of these reworkings will be debated here for pages and pages.
Want some other examples? Faith by George Michael. I love the song, but am sick of it at this point. That awful lame, ridiculous band Limp Croissant or Biscuit whatever remade it, and it was awesome. I could not stand any of their so called original songs. They were borderline Nickelback annoying to me. Their version turned an uptempo song into a hard rock song. If you have a lot of creativity, you can do an awful lot with existing songs. I just don't imagine U2 are up for the task, and as I have painfully over posted...if you look at all the artists who have made re-working albums, it usually is their lowest selling album of their career up to that point...see Bon Jovi, Sting, Sting, Sting(Sting has done a lot of them).
