Originally posted by kezman:So any of you lot excited about this new album of reworked songs? I'll be honest I'm struggling to be interested, really looking forward to the book though
Originally posted by beerok:[..]
To be honest, the news that most of the tracks will be the same usual warhorses has lowered my expectations a lot.
Originally posted by u2wanderer1:I’ll point out we were told about “Songs of Surrender” before the title of the book was announced or known. The book title was announced almost two months after we were told about the album title.
Originally posted by beerok:[..]
To be honest, the news that most of the tracks will be the same usual warhorses has lowered my expectations a lot.
Originally posted by LostSailor:[..]
Long post to follow:
I was becoming a bit intrigued by Songs of Surrender until I saw all of the Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience tracks. Not sure why any track off the last 2 albums has to be reworked. Especially for Songs of Innocence as we got the busker / acoustic versions of the those Innocence tunes on the deluxe version of the album. I know this has been stated here before....
Bottom Line:
I love Bono's storytelling and the animations. I am looking forward to reading the book. I am not enchanted with the this bloated project of 40 reworked songs...
We also found out that the Edge and Adam were recording U2 songs in stripped down arrangements during Lock Down. I wonder if this project grew and became a forced companion to Bono's 40 chapter book. Or did Bono intend for the band to re-record 40 songs at the very beginning of his book project?
Originally posted by SJKamal:I think they started off as 2 different projects. Bono was writing his book, whilst Edge got a "bee in his bonnet" and started to rework some of U2s songs. I assume somewhere down the line they then decided to merge the reworked songs with Bono's book. Ultimately creating one big project.