1. I have a sneaking suspicion This is gonna be one of those albums that the world loves and half of U2 fans are going to complain about lol. But I am very on board, it’s gonna be a long week.
  2. Originally posted by justinpushplay:I have a sneaking suspicion This is gonna be one of those albums that the world loves and half of U2 fans are going to complain about lol. But I am very on board, it’s gonna be a long week.
    That would be totally on point. I've never cared what albums or songs others like. I like NLOTH and many hate it.
  3. ''Even so, this is some of the band’s best work in more than 30 years.''
  4. I wonder will they regret not putting some of the stronger EP songs on there. For me there are some of their best tunes ever on those EPs - two or three of them.

    Obviously not heard majority of the album yet but just a thought.
  5. Tears of Things, In a Life, Resurrection Song, Scars and maybe Easter Parade are all looking like they would be great album tracks.

    I would include Coexist as well but I still enjoy the EP’s for what they are and remembering that they will still exist even if the album itself ended up as a disaster.
  6. Originally posted by ShineLikeStars94:I wonder will they regret not putting some of the stronger EP songs on there. For me there are some of their best tunes ever on those EPs - two or three of them.

    Obviously not heard majority of the album yet but just a thought.
    Agreed. It could have been like the White Album.
  7. Originally posted by germcevoy:Tears of Things, In a Life, Resurrection Song, Scars and maybe Easter Parade are all looking like they would be great album tracks.

    I would include Coexist as well but I still enjoy the EP’s for what they are and remembering that they will still exist even if the album itself ended up as a disaster.
    Very true. Agreed on all those songs.

    It is probably too early to say but time will tell if having a theme was the right move. Plus Torn doesn't seem to be linked to the theme too much. Think majority of listeners just want the best songs.

    Although as you say, it's not that we don't have the songs. And I'll be buying the two EPs on vinyl at some stage as well, so they are proper releases.
  8. Originally posted by germcevoy:Tears of Things, In a Life, Resurrection Song, Scars and maybe Easter Parade are all looking like they would be great album tracks.

    I would include Coexist as well but I still enjoy the EP’s for what they are and remembering that they will still exist even if the album itself ended up as a disaster.
    That's my fear , that an expanded EP album would have exceeded the quality of what is incoming on Friday. Let's be honest their decision making over last 15 years hasn't been great. Happy to be proved wrong on this.
  9. If they took the best from the EPs and put them on the album they would have risked not having the momentum and goodwill the EPs gave them. If those EPs got a bad reception the whole album would have been totally derailed and these positive reviews would have been considerable more painted with the U2 hatred we’ve come to expect.
  10. Part 3 of my Song by Song piece is up: https://www.u2songs.com/news/carnaval_de_luz_song_by_song_part_3

    Side two is the darker of the two sides of the album. “Torn” is a pretty heartbreaking ending to things, but it gets dark before that. I can definitely see how you go from side 2 into “Days of Ash”.

    Covers “Glorify”, “Midnight Sunshine”, “Can’t Stop Us Now”, “Torn” and a brief mention of the bonus track “Get Back to Now”