1. Originally posted by u2wanderer1:Part 3 of my Song by Song piece is up: https://www.u2songs.com/news/carnaval_de_luz_song_by_song_part_3

    Side two is the darker of the two sides of the album. “Torn” is a pretty heartbreaking ending to things, but it gets dark before that. I can definitely see how you go from side 2 into “Days of Ash”.

    Covers “Glorify”, “Midnight Sunshine”, “Can’t Stop Us Now”, “Torn” and a brief mention of the bonus track “Get Back to Now”


    I enjoyed reading through those, many thanks 🙂
  2. Reads to me that these are the ''better'' songs on the album judging by the reviews but everyone has an opinion right? 🙂

    It could be a wave of top tier tunes here...

    A+/A Tier
    Go
    La Reina
    Greatest Show on Earth
    If the World is at War we Better not be
    Glorify
    Midnight Sunshine - I suspect this might be the leader for its 'pop' sensibilities
    Can't Stop us Now
    Torn

    B Tier
    The Mirror Maker
    Streets of Dreams
    Silencio

    TBD
    Get back to Now
  3. I can’t get behind the Silencio slander!
  4. I quite like it, Its no Vertigo though is it.

    I'm really intrigued to know in what order all the album and EP songs were written.
  5. Originally posted by eddiecanb:[..]
    I quite like it, Its no Vertigo though is it.

    I'm really intrigued to know in what order all the album and EP songs were written.
    This one looks interesting, because it originated with Ryan Tedder in SoI/SoE era, but it looks like they dusted it off quite late in the recording process for CdL.
  6. Originally posted by eddiecanb:Reads to me that these are the ''better'' songs on the album judging by the reviews but everyone has an opinion right? 🙂

    It could be a wave of top tier tunes here...

    A+/A Tier
    Go
    La Reina
    Greatest Show on Earth
    If the World is at War we Better not be
    Glorify
    Midnight Sunshine - I suspect this might be the leader for its 'pop' sensibilities
    Can't Stop us Now
    Torn

    B Tier
    The Mirror Maker
    Streets of Dreams
    Silencio

    TBD
    Get back to Now
    Superficiality is another divisive song based on the reviews, I’m very curious about this one.
  7. Oh yes I missed that one 🙂
  8. Originally posted by eddiecanb:Reads to me that these are the ''better'' songs on the album judging by the reviews but everyone has an opinion right? 🙂

    It could be a wave of top tier tunes here...

    A+/A Tier
    Go
    La Reina
    Greatest Show on Earth
    If the World is at War we Better not be
    Glorify
    Midnight Sunshine - I suspect this might be the leader for its 'pop' sensibilities
    Can't Stop us Now
    Torn

    B Tier
    The Mirror Maker
    Streets of Dreams
    Silencio

    TBD
    Get back to Now
    That's the vibe I am getting too, that's why it's 4 stars

    And that's ok honestly, who would have thought we would be getting 8 great/very good U2 album songs in 2026?

    PLUS 8 great EP songs!

    Very grateful. And honestly, I think Mirror Maker, SOD, and Silencio will become growers with time....
    Achtung Baby and Zooropa were said to be weird at the beginning. Of course, this is not Achtung Baby, but we gotta give it to them for being experimental and that in that risk they are taking they have accomplished a revitalization and cracked very good songs along the process. That is how art and music works, it's a 50/50 chance of doing something great or not.

    Some people will find SOD great, others terrible.

    But I think we all can agree American Soul is terrible
  9. Originally posted by juandicorrea:[..]
    That's the vibe I am getting too, that's why it's 4 stars

    And that's ok honestly, who would have thought we would be getting 8 great/very good U2 album songs in 2026?

    PLUS 8 great EP songs!

    Very grateful. And honestly, I think Mirror Maker, SOD, and Silencio will become growers with time....
    Achtung Baby and Zooropa were said to be weird at the beginning. Of course, this is not Achtung Baby, but we gotta give it to them for being experimental and that in that risk they are taking they have accomplished a revitalization and cracked very good songs along the process. That is how art and music works, it's a 50/50 chance of doing something great or not.

    Some people will find SOD great, others terrible.

    But I think we all can agree American Soul is terrible
    I really like the Kendrick Lamarr song with U2, this was way better than AS.


    ''Its not a place, this country is to be a sound of Drum and Bass, you close your eyes to look around''.
  10. Originally posted by eddiecanb:[..]
    I quite like it, Its no Vertigo though is it.

    I'm really intrigued to know in what order all the album and EP songs were written.
    Glorify has been kicking around in another form since 2021.

    The early sessions in 2024 with Eno resulted in Go, Greatest Show, and Can’t Stop Us Now.

    Street of Dreams was early in the process so late 2024. Street of Dreams was one of the first things worked on when Larry was back, so post-Eno.

    Bono was talking up Superficiality in 2025 so probably midway through the process.

    Midnight Sunshine, Can’t Stop Us Now, Superficiality and Glorify were all mixed by NealHPogue, so may have been recorded around the same time. (both Glorify and Can’t Stop Us Now would have originated earlier.)

    Sounds like Torn and Silencio were both quite late. Greatest Show on Earth was mixed late in the process as was Silencio, so even though Greatest probably started early sounds like it was finished late.