Originally posted by germcevoy:I blame Guggi. I’ll never prove it but he’s a meddler and get in the bands ear too much in matters of creativity. Most likely Bono’s specifically. Clearly and obviously well respected by the band but I still think we’d have a simpler and better band and live show without Guggi.
Originally posted by germcevoy:I blame Guggi. I’ll never prove it but he’s a meddler and get in the bands ear too much in matters of creativity. Most likely Bono’s specifically. Clearly and obviously well respected by the band but I still think we’d have a simpler and better band and live show without Guggi.
Edit edit I MEANT GAVIN
Never thought about that at all. I wonder what makes you feel that way?
Originally posted by tuf392664:[..]
I’d disagree with that. It doesn’t ‘need’ to make a whole. If they put out an album with 10 very good- great songs then that’s a masterpiece. There is something enjoyable about songs that go well together but it’s not the be all and end all. There’s very few albums ever made that are a strong listen all the way through so this idea about an album having to be a whole I don’t really buy into too much. Better having 10 top quality songs instead of 8 and 2 average songs that ‘go well’ together.
What will be stopping you from listening to DOA -> EL -> CDL in this order in one go and why is it inferior to having a mishmash album of best songs from all three releases? It’s a great three-part album that will be listened to like this by true fans. Others won’t care. And fans will grumble anyway, whatever they do. If they truly released a best of type mishmash album then surely grumble would be about holding off all those great songs that we only know by names from Bono’s interviews but we will never get to hear. And surely all those would be (potential) masterpieces maliciously hidden by the band from the world.
What will be stopping you from listening to DOA -> EL -> CDL in this order in one go and why is it inferior to having a mishmash album of best songs from all three releases? It’s a great three-part album that will be listened to like this by true fans. Others won’t care. And fans will grumble anyway, whatever they do. If they truly released a best of type mishmash album then surely grumble would be about holding off all those great songs that we only know by names from Bono’s interviews but we will never get to hear. And surely all those would be masterpieces maliciously hidden by the band from the world.
I have no complaints with them releasing the 2 ep’s and the album the way they have. Actually I think it’s the best thing because I agree they probably wouldn’t have picked out the best songs to make 1 great album.
But my point stands that the quality of material is far more important than any theme or style running through an album. If you get quality and theme right however you end up with an all time great ( see Achtung baby) but I think at this stage of the bands career an Achtung Baby is impossible so just focus on quality.
In terms of how I listen to the material I’m sure I will listen to them that way on a few occasions but eventually weaker tracks will be deleted. In fact I’ve already deleted street of dreams.
Originally posted by tuf392664:[..]
I have no complaints with them releasing the 2 ep’s and the album the way they have. Actually I think it’s the best thing because I agree they probably wouldn’t have picked out the best songs to make 1 great album.
But my point stands that the quality of material is far more important than any theme or style running through an album. If you get quality and theme right however you end up with an all time great ( see Achtung baby) but I think at this stage of the bands career an Achtung Baby is impossible so just focus on quality.
In terms of how I listen to the material I’m sure I will listen to them that way on a few occasions but eventually weaker tracks will be deleted. In fact I’ve already deleted street of dreams.
Achtung Baby is a unique case. They were on the verge of breaking up; it was a matter of taking a risk or dying—all or nothing.