Top 10 U2 songs of all time? Yikes, it would take a lot for any of the new songs to crack that list, or even the top 20. In fact, it would take years of listening and personal experiences with the song.
The last U2 song that might have cracked my top ten all time is either Beautiful Day or Stay (both of which others have mentioned). Nothing on the last two albums even makes my top 30 list.
I'm just happy that I think that lots of songs on the EPs (and I hope the album) are really good songs. Better than most of what we've heard from them for a while.
It will be one great album to make a playlist and listen to: Days of Ash -> Fireflies -> Easter Lily -> Carnaval de Luz in this order. For me Fireflies makes sense between Yours Eternally and Song For Hal as it’s uplifting like the former and Edge’s song like the latter. So transition between songs with Fireflies included is good and without it Yours Eternally directly into Song For Hal sounds a little jarring.
Torn into American Obituary and COEXIST into Go have been apparently designed by the band to listen to back to back. So far it seems that there would be no place for Get Back to Now in this flow.
Originally posted by tuf392664:I wonder what the most recent song to make people’s top 10 is. I think I’d have to go back to Stay. A few since then in my top 20.
Good question. I don’t even have a top-10 I think. I revisit songs/albums/live shows when I feel like I need it and then preferences change. Of course I have my favorites but not sure I could compile a top-10. Top-20 would be easier.
Originally posted by SJKamal:One things for sure, combine half of the EPs with half of CL and you'll have a stellar album.
Not really. Such an album would be all over the place with political songs, religious songs, carnaval songs, uplifting songs, downbeat songs, rock songs, ballads, classic U2 sound, a touch of latino and also a bit of Achtung, Zooropa and POP to make even more mess. Themes musically and lyrically would be all over the place. I really think they did a very good thing with those three separate releases that somehow connect with each other and can still be listened to as a whole. A whole made of three distinct parts with different themes. I think it was a great move for them to release the material they had in this way and it will all hold up as a piece of art.
Live show is different than an album that will be listened to by millions and for ages. It needs to make a whole not a pile of songs, even if great individually.
Originally posted by Bonu:Live show is different than an album that will be listened to by millions and for ages. It needs to make a whole not a pile of songs, even if great individually.
I’d disagree with that. It doesn’t ‘need’ to make a whole. If they put out an album with 10 very good- great songs then that’s a masterpiece. There is something enjoyable about songs that go well together but it’s not the be all and end all. There’s very few albums ever made that are a strong listen all the way through so this idea about an album having to be a whole I don’t really buy into too much. Better having 10 top quality songs instead of 8 and 2 average songs that ‘go well’ together.
I blame Guggi. I’ll never prove it but he’s a meddler and get in the bands ear too much in matters of creativity. Most likely Bono’s specifically. Clearly and obviously well respected by the band but I still think we’d have a simpler and better band and live show without Guggi.