1. I would die for an album full of songs like this from them
  2. Originally posted by dcfrom79:For me, it doesn't have an absolute stand out anthem classic like a 'With or Without You', 'One' or even a 'Beautiful Day'* (yes GSOE is closest but not quite at that level). But it is, in my mind, the most interesting album U2 have created in a hell of a long time. I don't think U2 ever create a truly bad record, it's just the last few years, they've all been dull and safe and nothing unexpected. This corrects that. With Easter Lily and this, i think it's great stuff from a band in their 50th year.

    *I know U2 fans are bored of this song, but it is an anthemic classic - its the reason for its 26 year obiquity and familiarity breeds contempt and all that.
    Some good thoughts here. And I guess for once they didn't care so much about the stand-out track. Time will obviously tell but I think there's probably 4-5 brilliant songs here that will stand the test of time. Obviously feelings will fluctuate as the days and weeks go by on which those are.

    But it feels like an album they wanted to make rather than one they thought people wanted to hear.

    I think Can't Stop Us Now could develop into a real classic. Some of the turns of phrases and delivery are awesome.

    Also, while I'm here lol, some of the reviews mention lyrics etc. And when you read some lyrics out of context, fair enough, they jar. But as with any singer it's all about delivery. That 'sing a ling on the reggaeton' lyric sounds like nonsense when you read it, but I love how he sings on it and you barely notice it.
  3. One listen. It flows. It's cohesive. Will take a few more listens to digest the new tracks.
  4. Rosalia jumps out.
  5. They had writer's block. There really isn't any other excuse for Songs Of Surrendering To The Trend Of Old Artists Re-Recording Their Own Songs. The fact that it went 40 deep was way way beyond self-parody. It was insignificant on multiple levels.....

    The good news??? Songs Of Carnival is pretty good. Songs Of Ash and Songs Of Easter have some good songs as well. U2 are back! Or least mostly back.
  6. I’m wary of recency bias so I know this could change but I would say it’s their best album since ATYCLB quite comfortably at the moment. I think it’s even a little bit more consistent than ATYCLB but maybe doesn’t have quite as many of the real standouts. Sort of agreeing with dcfrom79’s comments above. Although I think after hearing the live performance of greatest show on earth that’s up there and can’t stop us now could be too, desperate to hear the live performances of that. I don’t any of the rest will jump into classic territory but a few 7 and 8/10’s which is a high standard.
  7. Bonos vocie is way to high mixed in those tracks.
    On Achtung Baby, Zooropa, Pop his voice was a part of the music and atmosphere.
    Now its his voice and the music...

    I really want to like this album, but its so much Chewgummi and the lyrics has some silly details here and there.
    Superficiality must have the most cringy/silly chours ever in a U2 song, worse than Stand Up Comedy.
    Glorify sound like a Backstreet Boys song("all the time, all the time") in the chours.
    Midnight Sunshine would have fit on a Zara Larsson album.

    Nine years to get a Chewgummi playground album...

    At least we got The Greatest Show On Earth, Songs Fo Hal, Silencio, American Obituary and One Life At A Time. Really good tracks.
  8. My thoughts on the songs:

    Go
    Shades of Zoo Station. Go feels like a statement of intent as it chugs along. Love this one. Only wish it was a bit longer.
    4/5

    La Reina
    Shades of Even Better Than the Real Thing. Catchy, groovy guitar. It's good, but not great. I do really enjoy the "nobody is alone/But nobody knows that/Everyone is on their own/Everybody knows that" lyric.
    3.5/5

    Street of Dreams
    Makes more sense on the record than it did as a single.
    3.5/5

    The Mirror Maker (Rosalia)
    I thought this one would be dumb but it's actually quite good. Catchy. I really love the lyric about the re-enchanting of the world. That feels like a bit of a mission statement.
    4/5

    Superficiality
    Interesting song. Very different. Love the falsetto but is it Bono or Edge?
    3.5/5

    If the World is at War We Better Not Be
    Not really a song, but it is a beautiful prayer.
    3/5

    Silencio
    This one has really grown on me. I do wish it was a minute longer.
    4/5

    The Greatest Show on Earth
    Classic U2. A song only U2 could make.
    4.5/5

    Glorify
    Love this. I don't think it's better than the sphere version, but it's still great. Super strong lyric. Doesn't really sound like a U2 song, but in a good way.
    4.5/5

    Midnight Sunshine
    This one is the one I'm not connecting with. There's nothing wrong with it, but its not as good as the songs before and after it - which makes it very skippable.
    2.5/5

    Can't Stop Us Now
    Great intro. As others have said, killer bass from Adam. Sounds a bit like Babyface. Would fit nicely on Pop. Good song.
    3.5/5

    Torn
    Beautiful, very moving. I was skeptical of the collab, but it's so good. Pulls the record back to earth emotionally with a thud. Heavy closer. Great lyrics. Points to American Obituary thematically really well.
    4.5/5

    Great record. Their best since Pop.
  9. Originally posted by ka23:I am very disappointed. I don’t like the album at all. Except for "The Greatest Show," the other songs don’t even reach the standard one would simply expect from U2.


    Give it another few listens
  10. Go - if this is what the Eno “sci-fi folk” project sounds like I’m going to die and go to heaven when that gets released in a Lost Albums boxed set in 20 years

    La Reina - we have Even Better Than the Real Thing at home but hey, worse things to emulate, and it’s just off kilter enough to feel new

    Street of Dreams - not quite the way I expected this to be integrated. I don’t know where on this is landing on the spectrum of tired of it to growing on me, we’ll see on later listens when it doesn’t stand out as “oh yeah, heard this, don’t think much of it”

    Mirror Maker - as weird as it is to be singing about Rosalia, this track kinda goes off, band having a lot of fun, their big time rock stuff doesn’t always work for me but this sounds great

    Superficiality - saw a lot of people saying this was the low point of the album. I guess that’s probably based mainly around Bono’s lyrics being cheesy or whatever. I’m not really minding it, but my ear is more tuned in to the other three guys and they’re sounding great

    If The World Is At War - almost didn’t realize this had started and it wasn’t just the last one. Very much in the vein of Coexist. Kind of interesting as an interlude, will have to see how it grows on me

    Silencio - speaking of, this one has grown on me a lot, it’s very catchy. Feels pretty at home on this album (unlike Street of Dreams which is still feeling like a head scratcher to me)

    Greatest Show on Earth - weirdly this is feeling a little out of place, maybe not on the album as a whole but definitely coming after Silencio (maybe would make more sense after the look back at the band forming in If The World Is At War). Regardless, this is feeling pretty confidently like their best song of all the releases this year

    Glorify - they played a version of this over the loudspeakers as the exit music at the Sphere. This one is basically nothing like that, very interesting angle on this, bringing a bit of the Songs of Surrender acoustic vibe with kind of a funky edge. Into it

    Midnight Sunshine - I don’t know what the hell this is. Kind of sounds like an All That You Can’t Leave Behind outtake put through a Taylor Swift filter (which I don’t mean as much of an insult as it sounds, but I don’t really mean it as complimentary either). It’s so low key and almost effortless it doesn’t feel too much like straining over-produced poppy bullshit, but I don’t really like it either

    Can’t Stop Us Now - this feels like the band and Eno picking up where they left off on No Line on the Horizon. Just a catchy 6 minute groove (with sort of a Revolver flair), definitely the one I want to go right back to

    Torn - I’ll be honest, I was kind of worried about the Dolly feature just because I didn’t know if the combo would really make sense sonically, but this works pretty well, I don’t know if it’s going into the pantheon of U2 album closers but it’ll sit nicely alongside stuff like The Wanderer and The Troubles