Originally posted by BonoIsTheMessiah:I'm up late here on the U.S. East Coast listening to this album for the second time. I don't get the negative reviews. I have the same feeling listening to this that I had when Atomic Bomb first came out. Every song is great. The difference from Atomic Bomb is that there is a unifying theme. When you put Carnaval together with the two EPs, this is the best work they have done since Pop/All That You Can't Leave Behind (whichever of those albums you prefer) and quite possibly (time and many, many listens will tell) since Achtung Baby. This album is a glorious return to form.
I heard the deluxe version. It's a masterpiece with all 24 songs heard in context. Best work since Atomic bomb and loved No Line
For me, it doesn't have an absolute stand out anthem classic like a 'With or Without You', 'One' or even a 'Beautiful Day'* (yes GSOE is closest but not quite at that level). But it is, in my mind, the most interesting album U2 have created in a hell of a long time. I don't think U2 ever create a truly bad record, it's just the last few years, they've all been dull and safe and nothing unexpected. This corrects that. With Easter Lily and this, i think it's great stuff from a band in their 50th year.
*I know U2 fans are bored of this song, but it is an anthemic classic - its the reason for its 26 year obiquity and familiarity breeds contempt and all that.
Rosalia and La Reina should have been singles. Very sonically diverse but clearly the lads are having fun. Torn is the official crying song. Bono and Dolly Parton work really well together vocally.
The only one I am not feeling yet is Superficiality , thanks to Bono's chanting, Edge saves it in the chorus and guitar wise.
I have a lot written down but my first impressions are positive. I feel so lucky to be a U2 fan. This is a great album. Their most exciting record sonically since NLOTH.
I am very disappointed. I don’t like the album at all. Except for "The Greatest Show," the other songs don’t even reach the standard one would simply expect from U2.
Originally posted by ka23:I am very disappointed. I don’t like the album at all. Except for "The Greatest Show," the other songs don’t even reach the standard one would simply expect from U2.
That’s interesting! That is indeed the most U2-like song on the record. But I am loving the rest of the album!