1. I’m following a global discussion in defense of the new album, which raises the question: what other band could pull off a Carnaval de Luz after so many years in the game
  2. Originally posted by Swfan42:Re: U2songs story about there being multiple mixes of the album out there depending on format, I noticed there was no mention of what’s on the Blu Ray.

    Does anyone here know if the mixes on the Blu Ray are more similar to the vinyl or digital?
    It was not mentioned cause Blu-ray just got the standard stereo digital mix that also went to streaming and CD. On Blu-ray it’s in high-res quality though (24bit/48kHz) compared to standard CD quality (16bit/44.1kHz) but difference between the two isn’t really audible as all proper blind listening tests suggest. So for all purposes stereo mix is the same across all digital formats.

    Dolby Atmos multi-channel mix that is also available on Blu-ray is a different matter.
  3. Does anyone know how well the album is doing in the charts or is it too early to tell so far?

  4. First proper listen coming up.
  5. I enjoyed that. Side 2 particularly. Edge is nowhere and I can’t recall a single memorable lyric. I only notice Adams great work.

    Easter Lily is a much better body of work, potentially because it is immediately more accessible in terms of song structures and melodies.

    No idea where I’ll end up with CdL but I am happy that I actually like it over the course of the first weekend.

    All uses of vocal effects on this album were totally pointless and added nothing.
  6. Originally posted by germcevoy:I enjoyed that. Side 2 particularly. Edge is nowhere and I can’t recall a single memorable lyric. I only notice Adams great work.

    Easter Lily is a much better body of work, potentially because it is immediately more accessible in terms of song structures and melodies.

    No idea where I’ll end up with CdL but I am happy that I actually like it over the course of the first weekend.

    All uses of vocal effects on this album were totally pointless and added nothing.
    Glad to read that your opinion of the album has changed a bit for the better.

    I do agree with Edge not featuring anything memorable and the vocal effects
  7. Listened to the whole CDL/DOA/EL. Outstanding work. Such a powerful and, at times, truly mesmerizing body of work. For them to have such a strong, creative output in their 50th year is, in my opinion, phenomenal and certainly not to be taken for granted.

    As for the comments on The Edge, I guess people are referring specifically to CDL and not the EPs. I definitely wouldn’t say that he is nowhere. He is very much alive and kicking in La Reina, The Mirror Maker, Silencio, The Greatest Show On Earth, and Can’t Stop Us Now does have some interesting guitar playing. Of course, there are no solos, so I assume Edge made a conscious decision to leave them out, perhaps feeling that these songs simply didn’t call for them. My thoughts.