Originally posted by germcevoy:I enjoyed that. Side 2 particularly. Edge is nowhere and I can’t recall a single memorable lyric. I only notice Adams great work.
Easter Lily is a much better body of work, potentially because it is immediately more accessible in terms of song structures and melodies.
No idea where I’ll end up with CdL but I am happy that I actually like it over the course of the first weekend.
All uses of vocal effects on this album were totally pointless and added nothing.
Vocal effects are not pointless for a band kicking and screaming to be relevant...so the use of modern "music" trends is expected. I really do like the Songs Of Carnival album, but the vocal effects didn't ruin the album for me. Perhaps a 3.8/5 downgraded to 3.5. At least there is nothing as awful as Auto Tune Is All We Have Left.
Originally posted by iamcrazytonight:Listened to the whole CDL/DOA/EL. Outstanding work. Such a powerful and, at times, truly mesmerizing body of work. For them to have such a strong, creative output in their 50th year is, in my opinion, phenomenal and certainly not to be taken for granted.
As for the comments on The Edge, I guess people are referring specifically to CDL and not the EPs. I definitely wouldn’t say that he is nowhere. He is very much alive and kicking in La Reina, The Mirror Maker, Silencio, The Greatest Show On Earth, and Can’t Stop Us Now does have some interesting guitar playing. Of course, there are no solos, so I assume Edge made a conscious decision to leave them out, perhaps feeling that these songs simply didn’t call for them. My thoughts.
Well to be fair, he does have some major contributions to Song of the Future, Resurrection Song and La Reina, specially the intro.
But the fact that one scrambles to find such moments says something
Same as what? Mix on CD is the same as on streaming platforms and Blu-ray. Only vinyl mix is different cause it was done earlier to make it in time for vinyl production.
Then I don’t know how many times they tweaked this and how many different mixes we have in result. Obvious differences are between digital and vinyl mix, especially with Go and Mirror Maker. I believe that any differences between digital formats can only be minor if they even exist.
I’ve read nearly all the reviews here over the last few days and have listened to the album about a dozen times now.
This is such a wide fan base and it’s impossible that everyone will like an album once it comes out. We all have come to the table at different times over the last 50 years. What constitutes a good or great album will vary from fan to fan as U2 means different things to different people.
I remember the debates before and after Achtung Baby came out. The idea of the band singing loud political anthems inside stadiums was replaced with Bono in all leather singing about a Fly whilst wearing sunglasses and smoking a cigar. It took time for everyone to jump on board - with the live shows really helping everyone get this new direction.
Up until this year many in these forums have thought the group might be finished in terms of new music. This year has dispelled that myth.
If any of you are West Wing fans there is a famous episode where the punchline is ‘ Let Bartlett be Bartlett’. This year I feel they are moving away from looking for the next biggest hit, staying relevant via various producers and looking for the next big sound. This year we have seen ‘Let U2 be U2’.
They caught us totally off guard with the EPs. Easter Lily lifted us all especially as we had never thought a second EP would appear so quickly. U2 flying by their pants sees them take chances and gor for it. I feel it’s when they are at their best.
This new album has a great song - TGSOE. What a performance already on the BBC. A song that continues to lift you as it moves along, as Bad and WOWY have done before. The video shows all 4 of them at their best and this should lift you up too.
It seems fresh but brings me back to the Unforgettable Fire and Achtung Baby in particular. It has some good songs and sounds elsewhere including La Reina and The Mirror Maker. Others are growing on me - was anyone confident U2 and Dolly Parton would work ? What a song and it gets better with every listen. It is true that some songs aren’t getting me at the moment.
This debate here and elsewhere I think is refreshing as we all grabble with another new version of our band circa 1987, 1991, 1997, 2001, 2009, 2015 and 2026. Don’t be too quick to judge as they often leave us looking foolish as they pull another rabbit out of the hat. When you think of it - what other band can do what they have done this week after 50 years together?
The tour will see all the songs evolve as will the band. Let U2 be U2 and roll on 2027!!!
There's another difference in the CD version that I caught - "Glorify" has a mistake in the lyrics when Bono sings "We're made from each other, you and I/'Cause we're made from each other" the first time instead of "We're made for each other, you and I". This is corrected in the streaming version.