SOS
Active topics
U2 - Songs Of Surrender (2023)
 Tracks: 40
  2. Basically the same piano version we've been hearing for almost 10 years, but tuned down a whole step (in Bm instead of C#m).

    So much for "reimaginating" lol
  4. Was really hoping for some lyric changes at least.
  5. Originally posted by LikeASong:Basically the same piano version we've been hearing for almost 10 years, but tuned down a whole step (in Bm instead of C#m).

    So much for "reimaginating" lol
    The original piano version had the perfect key as it was on the threshold if his upper register and he was putting in the effort which made it better This new version sounds too easy and almost "relaxed".
  6. Originally posted by LikeASong:Basically the same piano version we've been hearing for almost 10 years, but tuned down a whole step (in Bm instead of C#m).

    So much for "reimaginating" lol
    The original piano version had the perfect key as it was on the threshold if his upper register and he was putting in the effort which made it better This new version sounds too easy and almost "relaxed".
  7. Originally posted by EthanD:[..]
    The original piano version had the perfect key as it was on the threshold if his upper register and he was putting in the effort which made it better This new version sounds too easy and almost "relaxed".
    Yep, sounds lazy and much less passionate than the original piano version.
  8. I don’t mind this too much just because I’m happy they didn’t murder the original, lol, but did it really need to be 5 minutes? Damn.

    And yeah, this really isn’t much different than what we already had from the acoustic sessions of SOI.
  9. Was this really necessary?
    We already had two (two!!) piano versions!
    What a waste of one of the places on the album
  10. Yeah, feels like the worst thing about this track is the loss of potential for something more interesting.
  11. This has easily been my least favorite track so far because I’ve never liked the piano versions of this song and this one is way too similar to the other two to justify its existence.
  12. I always liked the piano one myself but can see it’s a bit duplicative, I did like this one