1. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    As someone who makes music, obviously at a very different level lol , I will say one of the hardest decisions to make when you’re putting together an album is whether or not you wanna just put the strongest collection of songs together, or if you want the songs to have some sort of connective DNA that makes it feel like a body at work. I’m sure tears of things is definitely good enough to be on the album, but maybe sonic and lyrically it just doesn’t fit the rest of the motif. Joshua Tree is a perfect example, that entire album sounds like one piece of work, and while sweetest thing, is a better song than trip through your wires, it would’ve stuck out like a sore thumb on the record
    I expect you're hitting the nail on the head. I expect they've been working on an album which has a strong focus. Not sure if that's theme, or type of songs, that they are all in Spanish, or whatever it is, but the songs on "Easter Lily" and "Days of Ash" didn't fit for whatever reason. Bono has spoken multiple times about Carnival and celebration in relation to the album.

    I suspect the EPs were born out of knowing they had some good work, that would sit and not get released for another couple of years if they waited for the 'next' album, so they pushed through to get them out while they were still fresh. In the end, they were released. We got some really good songs, and we got them earlier than we would have if the band had stuck to traditional cycles.
  2. I dream of an album that is more than a collection of songs. UF, JT, AB and Zoorppa are all albums full of work that sounds like it came from the one vein of creativity. You can feel it as you listen to them. NLOTH started out on the same path then slowly but surely got pegged back more and more and ended up with songs on there that felt like afterthoughts

    It just surprises me greatly that they can be far enough down the line to film a video for the lead single and then kinda go dark. You must know what you have by that point? You must surely know what the vision was and whether what was created meets that vision? That’s when I want them to commit. When they second guess and start to doubt, that’s when mediocrity kicks in.

    Who knows whether that’s what is at play. Something not formally announced cannot be delayed (presuming it comes out this year).

    Just give us what you’ve got.
  3. Just hasn't been the same since Pop/Popmart. I miss those days when they would challenge themselves artistically with every new album.
  4. This is really random, but I just really wanna see the portion of the video which they filmed in Salón Los Angeles. 😎 🍻
  5. I don't get what the rush is to hear the single. I'm personally still just enjoying the last 2 EPs. The band can take as long as they want to release it and I don't mind. I'm not going to jump to conclusions based on crumbs, and I'm definitely not going to reevaluate my entire journey as a fan just to show whether or not I'm frustrated with a single that hasn't even come out yet. I'm going to try to enjoy this period of uncertainty around the band and appreciate the ones that were released this year.
  6. Originally posted by hedyzera:I don't get what the rush is to hear the single. I'm personally still just enjoying the last 2 EPs. The band can take as long as they want to release it and I don't mind. I'm not going to jump to conclusions based on crumbs, and I'm definitely not going to reevaluate my entire journey as a fan just to show whether or not I'm frustrated with a single that hasn't even come out yet. I'm going to try to enjoy this period of uncertainty around the band and appreciate the ones that were released this year.
    I think tone can be lost on a forum, because I'm personally not reevaluating my journey as a fan, or anything that drastic - I'm simply having fun and posting the occasional comment to engage with other fans, and keep the forum going. Although they played at Sphere, I was unable to go, so it's felt like a bit of a 'void' for me. When they finally start the next promo cycle, it will finally feel 'certain' to me that they're definitely going to 'come back', even though I know it's not in any doubt! I'm in my 40s, and have been a fan for over 25 years, so I'm certainly not in any hurry - I know 'this too shall pass', so once the next promo cycle starts, the album is released, and the tour begins, it will inevitably all feel like it's gone very quickly, so I'll be cherishing every moment. Fans are understandably going to be eagerly anticipating the single and video which was much publicised by U2 and their official website, but we're all adults, and we understand that there will be a reason behind the delay. 🍻 Editing to add that I was completely overjoyed by the release of the two EPs, and they're amongst my most listened to music on Spotify.
  7. Not sure if anyone has mentioned this but can’t we just have Easter Lilly on CD😭
  8. Originally posted by justinpushplay:[..]
    As someone who makes music, obviously at a very different level lol , I will say one of the hardest decisions to make when you’re putting together an album is whether or not you wanna just put the strongest collection of songs together, or if you want the songs to have some sort of connective DNA that makes it feel like a body at work. I’m sure tears of things is definitely good enough to be on the album, but maybe sonic and lyrically it just doesn’t fit the rest of the motif. Joshua Tree is a perfect example, that entire album sounds like one piece of work, and while sweetest thing, is a better song than trip through your wires, it would’ve stuck out like a sore thumb on the record


    I agree that this was most likely the reason why we received the EPs: they just had very good songs that didn’t fit with the album that they had been planning. I love cohesive albums that feel like one body of work. All their best albums have been like that and not just collections of random songs, however good they were. Having said that, I’m worried to hear the new album where apparently songs as good (and as different from one another both musically and thematically) as Tears Of Things, One Life At A Time, In A Life, Scars, Song For Hal, Resurrection Song, Easter Parade and COEXIST suddenly all didn’t fit… so what fits?
  9. "A double vinyl for Days of Ash and Easter Lily would be absolutely amazing. I'd love to see it in a dark purple look paired with a beautiful yellow!"