1. This song is a reason for U2 to still exist. I say every album just give me 1 or 2 songs to take with me going forward, or maybe 1 that could be one of their best, and I'll be happy. This is without a doubt one of those songs.
  2. The live arrangement only makes the song better. Edge takes it to another place which is not easy to do, it’s already in the stratosphere!
  3. Best song in over 20 years (opinion)
  4. Oddest track on the album. It’s just so much bigger, grander and much more ‘U2’ than anything else on the record.

    Did they throw us a bone here amidst so much different-sounding material?
  5. I really wish they didn’t release this as a single. One of my favorite u2 songs in a very very long time. I would’ve loved to get hit with this during my first listen through.
  6. Originally posted by germcevoy:Oddest track on the album. It’s just so much bigger, grander and much more ‘U2’ than anything else on the record.

    Did they throw us a bone here amidst so much different-sounding material?
    I think Little Things was an attempt at this but never really worked like GSOE does.
  7. I think next year at the concert I won't be able to stop crying with this song
  8. I went to every tour between 1992 and 2010, and I only went to The Joshua Tree Tour 2017 once, for nostalgic reasons. But I need to hear TGSOE in a stadium. It gives me the same excitement I felt when I became a fan as a ten-year-old boy in 1987. Just WOW!

    I still want to listen to this song each and every day. Amazing feeling!
  9. That live version…when the band stops playing at the beginning of “love is a business” and comes back in later. Incredible. Just when I thought this song couldn’t get any better.
  10. Originally posted by bpt3:That live version…when the band stops playing at the beginning of “love is a business” and comes back in later. Incredible. Just when I thought this song couldn’t get any better.
    Larry speaks of that new live version in the Anthony Mason podcast.
  11. Finally got around to listening to the live version. Wow.

    I remember thinking all this time that the only thing missing from this perfect song was an instrumental section where it's just the band playing... And now they've delivered. Takes the ending to another level. I think with a bit of polish this is going to be an absolute show stopper and staple beyond this tour.
  12. Reminds me a bit of The Little Things That Give You Away… same vibe or something