Originally posted by ric:Yep, U2 at their absolute prime for sure. Back in the days when they didn't take forever to overthink and overproduce and subsequently ruin an album just to try and make it as commercial as possible. Back when they were exciting, original and challenging. This was the first U2 album I ever bought (on cassette tape). How I miss those days... Cannot believe it's been 30 years.
And yes, this 30 year anniversary is a massive missed opportunity to release some of those demos of early versions of the album tracks, unheard songs, HMTMKMKM, the Bono version of Wanderer and most importantly demos of the songs that would end up on Pop. Surely there's a whole treasure trove of stuff related to this album that could've gone on a bonus disc or two. Now THAT is something I wouldn't have minded spending my hard earned £ on rather than a pointless, overpriced yellow vinyl...
i wonder whether because they had reached their apex (JT and AB) that they thought 'well, we've done that so let's try something new as we're never gonna reach that again' and therefore a release of experimentation took place
that led also to POP but that wasn't as great (though it really was) a success as JT and AB and they got scared, thought it all up again (where have we heard that before) and decided on the more mainstream route as that would enhance their legacy rather than end on that unsuccessful (to them) album
9/11 was a terrible terrible tragedy (act of terrorism) and we have to admit that as long-time fans, the album ATYCLB and tour touched a LOT of people's hearts and brought them to the fore again
the superbowl show was a superb spectacle that again showed a band that cared
and it might be controversial to say this, but without 9/11 would that show have been as memorable?
the albums post ATYCLB have been a real mish-mash (as have been some of their business dealings) with the last 2 (3 counting SOS) maybe looking backwards too much rather than looking forward