1. Maybe an 'unpopular' opinion or not, but I think With Or Without You has been one the few U2 songs that hasn't always transferred well live apart from some few stronger performances.

    It felt rejuvenated on the Elevation tour and some of the Joshua Tree anniversary shows, but it's almost become karaoke at times or the band felt obliged to play it. I don't know, maybe it's been overplayed but there's a certain feel on record it hasn't quite reached apart from the Rattle and Hum performance.
  2. Originally posted by EridescoFly:Maybe an 'unpopular' opinion or not, but I think With Or Without You has been one the few U2 songs that hasn't always transferred well live apart from some few stronger performances.

    It felt rejuvenated on the Elevation tour and some of the Joshua Tree anniversary shows, but it's almost become karaoke at times or the band felt obliged to play it. I don't know, maybe it's been overplayed but there's a certain feel on record it hasn't quite reached apart from the Rattle and Hum performance.
    I do agree with you for the most part. I know I've grown bored of it over the years. And I do sense sometimes it's just there because they are expected to play it. Will say that the shows at Sphere it became sort of a high point for me instead. Felt like it had some life back in it. Really grew to look forward to it at those shows...
  3. WOWY has been a moving target. I thought it got some new life in 2015, was fine for 2017/19, and a nice highlight at the Sphere.

    For the 360 shows, my general fatigue of the day (recording soundcheck, setting up gear, etc.) would catch up to me by the end of the show. I always enjoyed Ultraviolet and Hold Me... but would take a mental nap during WOWY during the encore.
  4. Originally posted by hoserama:WOWY has been a moving target. I thought it got some new life in 2015, was fine for 2017/19, and a nice highlight at the Sphere.

    For the 360 shows, my general fatigue of the day (recording soundcheck, setting up gear, etc.) would catch up to me by the end of the show. I always enjoyed Ultraviolet and Hold Me... but would take a mental nap during WOWY during the encore.
    Agree about the I&E tour too, it seemed to resonate more.
  5. Imo the last time it sounded great live was 2015.
  6. I'm not sure I've ever heard a great version of WOWY live. Nothing, for sure, that can compare to the versions from the original JT tour. To me it's one that can only really be done right with Bono's voice of that era. That said, I do like what he did with it in his solo show. He found the power in a different place and accessed real vulnerability in the first part (rather than sounding like he is forcing the emotion).
  7. Well, just my little view for what it's worth, but Glasgow Hydro 2nd night in 2015 was a total WOWY highlight: Shine Like Stars / Barrowlands improv. (Also the night of the int'l flag collecting / waving during Bad!)
  8. God that latest interview is full of word salad but more concerning are the complete contradictions between each members thoughts and even contradictory views between themselves individually .. I just don't believe a word this band says anymore. It's always manufactured word salad and useless metaphors!
  9. Originally posted by DaddyGJ:Well, just my little view for what it's worth, but Glasgow Hydro 2nd night in 2015 was a total WOWY highlight: Shine Like Stars / Barrowlands improv. (Also the night of the int'l flag collecting / waving during Bad!)
    +1

    Bono also threw in Love Will Tear Us Apart snippet.At that time,first time in 20+ years both Shine & Love Will snippets both together in WOWY
  10. I always asked myself how forceful bono would be by answering some artist who criticises U2, why did he never do it? For example Liam Gallagher and his numerous criticisms of the band
  11. Originally posted by Damonio123:I always asked myself how forceful bono would be by answering some artist who criticises U2, why did he never do it? For example Liam Gallagher and his numerous criticisms of the band
    Pretty much everyone has criticised U2 at some point, he probably just hasn't got the time to respond😂
  12. And why should he respond?
    U2 don't need to explain anything to anyone.