Originally posted by kezman:I posted recently on another thread I feel so bored with the band,I seem to just listen to bootlegs now.I agree that their best days are gone,times have moved on and they are kinda old hat.However I do think they can put out some really decent stuff for where they are in their career,SOS wasn't my kind of thing at all,but an album similar to the stuff before it? Why not? Innocence/Experience isn't their career highs but they were good for a band 35-40 years into a career.
I’m not bored as I’ll always listen to the albums and gigs, but the wait for a new album is definitely pissing me off
Has any band equaled or surpassed the 20 year run of brilliance that U2 had?
Well, Bowie did much more in just over 10 years (1969-1980) than U2 did in 20 years and he did it alone, always staying in charge and picking best musicians he could find for his projects in that period. And then, after a short period of mediocrity, he had the age of brilliance again in 1993-2016. His last album Blackstar is one of his career greatest. I doubt the last album of U2 will have a chance to be perceived like that. His last 3 albums before Blackstar were absolutely great too (Heathen, Reality, The Next Day). This is the way to finish a great career with class. Also, when he was recording Blackstar he was 4 years older than Bono is today. And in much worse health.
Bowie illustrates my point. There are many solo artists (Bowie, Dylan, Springsteen, Nick Cave, Joni Mitchell) who made/make great art into their old age, working with a wide range of collaborators.
But have any true bands (like U2, with a consistent lineup) made truly GREAT music for more than a decade or two?
Rush? R.E.M.? Queen? If you allow lineup changes also Genesis, Pink Floyd, Yes, King Crimson, Fleetwood Mac, Deep Purple: they all made great music for more than a decade or two, just with different people. In fact Genesis and Floyd were only reducing lineups with core members intact.
Bands are temporary. Most don’t even exist as long as 10 or 20 years. Many exist just because of long-term contracts and are nothing more than a trademark. How many bands do you have in jazz? Not many. Most are solo artists. Which means that bands don’t form naturally if there’s no big money involved.
Originally posted by dstankie:Bowie illustrates my point. There are many solo artists (Bowie, Dylan, Springsteen, Nick Cave, Joni Mitchell) who made/make great art into their old age, working with a wide range of collaborators.
But have any true bands (like U2, with a consistent lineup) made truly GREAT music for more than a decade or two?
Metallica, Def Leppard, Depeche mode,AC⚡️DC,Foo fighters have made some decent albums over a few decades with one or two changes in personnel.
Originally posted by dstankie:Bowie illustrates my point. There are many solo artists (Bowie, Dylan, Springsteen, Nick Cave, Joni Mitchell) who made/make great art into their old age, working with a wide range of collaborators.
But have any true bands (like U2, with a consistent lineup) made truly GREAT music for more than a decade or two?
Lineup changes don't count if we're comparing to U2.
Rush? R.E.M., Queen? If you allow lineup changes also Genesis, Pink Floyd, Yes, King Crimson, Fleetwood Mac, Deep Purple
Rush is an interesting possible exception, though I'll have to take your word for it as I don't understand their thing. REM had about a twenty year run, but would anyone argue their last few albums were of much importance? All the others here are disqualified from the comparison since they had signifiant personal changes.
Metallica, Def Leppard, Depeche mode,AC⚡️DC,Foo fighters have made some decent albums over a few decades with one or two changes in personnel.
"Decent" albums don't count. 🙂
Anyway, my basic point was that it's really hard (if not impossible) for bands made up of the same lineup to continue making great/significant music for very long.
From my perspective, U2 gave us a 20 year run of brilliance and important music followed by a kind of unfocussed 25 year mixed bag.
INXS didn’t quite make it to 20 years but their run up until Full Moon, Dirty Hearts sets them apart from most other bands. For me that one album is the only blemish on their career. Up to Michael’s death that is. The post-Michael period was difficult to stomach