My wife and I both love No Line, but we've often discussed how it is such a 'what if?' for the band.
A while ago I made an alternate mix of the album which has become our preferred version:
1. Soon
2. Unknown Caller
3. Breathe
4. Winter (Linnear Version)
5. White as Snow
6. No Line on the Horizon
7. Fez/Being Born
8. Magnificent
9. Every Breaking Wave (SOE album guitar version) - Some version of EBW was meant to be on NLOTH
10. Moment of Surrender
11. Cedars of Lebanon
To this day, I continue to scratch my head wonder how so many people hate GOYB. Just a thought that came to mind looking at people's different alternate album versions
Originally posted by thefly108:To this day, I continue to scratch my head wonder how so many people hate GOYB. Just a thought that came to mind looking at people's different alternate album versions
A lot of people do hate GOYB. For the record, I quite like it, but I don't think it should be on No Line. I don't think it fits with the other songs.
As an individual track, I really enjoy Boots, a lot of people lump Elevation, Vertigo and Boots all together, but I think Boots is a much more interesting song. It's actually quite weird - which I like.
I think GOYB is okay, but it shouldn't have been released as a single. I really like No Line as an experimental album like UF and Zooropa, but I thought they ruined it by including Stand-Up Comedy. I would have left out Stand-Up Comedy and added Soon, Every Breaking Wave, and No Line on the Horizon 2.
Originally posted by Sashlon1138:My wife and I both love No Line, but we've often discussed how it is such a 'what if?' for the band.
A while ago I made an alternate mix of the album which has become our preferred version:
1. Soon
2. Unknown Caller
3. Breathe
4. Winter (Linnear Version)
5. White as Snow
6. No Line on the Horizon
7. Fez/Being Born
8. Magnificent
9. Every Breaking Wave (SOE album guitar version) - Some version of EBW was meant to be on NLOTH
10. Moment of Surrender
11. Cedars of Lebanon
I think that would have been a classic.
Yes, this would have been a better album -- perhaps comparable in quality to Unforgettable Fire.
I understand NLOTH is beloved by many fans, but it's probably my least favorite U2 album. To this day I can't figure out what they were trying to do thematically, musically, etc. I will say some of the songs sounded incredible live and 360 Tour was a blast.