1. I think if they would have gone with less "polished" mixes, it would have been better... It's kind of like POP. The live versions of Every Breaking Wave and Iris are so massively superior to the album versions.

    A very solid album nonetheless.
  2. Iris
    This is Where you can reach me
    Song for Someone
    Every Breaking Wave
    Trouble
    Sleep like a baby
    Raised by Wolves....

    At least 7 very very good songs in an album that was given away free.
  3. Originally posted by TRISTAN:Iris
    This is Where you can reach me
    Song for Someone
    Every Breaking Wave
    Trouble
    Sleep like a baby ....

    At least 6 very very good songs in an album that was given away free.
    those are really good songs, I've hooked on Sleep like a baby, and the soundscape is really really good!
  4. I like every song on the album. Some more than others but don’t dislike any of it and wouldn’t want different mixes or versions on the album either. I think it’s the best album u2 could make at that point in their career and I doubt if they’ll ever be able to better it in the future, but I hope I’m wrong about that.
  5. Originally posted by tuf392664:I like every song on the album. Some more than others but don’t dislike any of it and wouldn’t want different mixes or versions on the album either. I think it’s the best album u2 could make at that point in their career and I doubt if they’ll ever be able to better it in the future, but I hope I’m wrong about that.
    Agreed.
  6. This album is #3 or #4 for me depending on the day. It’s got my favorite three-song intro since Achtung Baby, and I love how cohesive and polished it feels. It even has stellar B-sides, with Crystal Ballroom and Lucifer’s Hands. I think it’s a real shame Every Breaking Wave was only performed stripped down, and I wish California had gotten more time to shine. Only track I don’t like is Cedarwood Road, but I know that’s a pretty unpopular opinion!
  7. It's not a 'great' album by any means but has its high points - I'd say it's on a par with SOE (though many hate that album)

    Possibly on a par with ATYCLB too - now that's controversial
  8. There are really good songs on this album!
  9. Originally posted by RedSky:It's not a 'great' album by any means but has its high points - I'd say it's on a par with SOE (though many hate that album)

    Possibly on a par with ATYCLB too - now that's controversial
    While I don’t think the SOI has as high of peaks as ATYCLB does, as a full album I think it’s very comparable and more consistent in quality across the whole tracklist. Neither are perfect but as many have said, I think SOI gets way too much negative media commentary because of the release method. The songs themselves are really solid.

    I think EBW (all versions!) and Iris are incredibly good U2 songs and tracks 7-11 are an incredibly consistent finish to the album. SOI is definitely under appreciated imo.
  10. all of you are saying fax, so good reviews
  11. The trio of volcano-raised by wolves and cedarwood road is the best part of the album, as epic as U2 always knew how to do it
  12. Best U2 album of the 21st century