1. 1. Crystal Ballroom should've been on the album
    2. It should've been the first single

    That is all 😛
  2. Agreed. It could have been the Get Lucky of that year
  3. I wonder if it's the similarities to Stones' Miss You that made them leave it out. Never really occurred to me until Bono snippeted it when they played the song live.
  4. Originally posted by Hansav:I wonder if it's the similarities to Stones' Miss You that made them leave it out. Never really occurred to me until Bono snippeted it when they played the song live.
    They probably didn't want a Bittersweet Symphony situation! 😛
  5. Originally posted by RedSky:It's not a 'great' album by any means but has its high points - I'd say it's on a par with SOE (though many hate that album)

    Possibly on a par with ATYCLB too - now that's controversial


    Controversial? Try this..SOI is in my top 3 behind JT and AB
  6. Eh. Sounds like a cheesy 70s band. Great Edge solo, though.
  7. Wow ahead of POP, Zooropa, RAH and TUF?

    Hey, but if you like it you like it - and that's all that matters
  8. I might be crazy in thinking this

    But I think at some point down the line SOI is going to get popular. Suddenly, people are going to realize that album U2 forced on the public was pretty decent after all. It might take another decade for that to happen or the death of Bono but I think it’s going to happen.
  9. Originally posted by Bonoboy92:I might be crazy in thinking this

    But I think at some point down the line SOI is going to get popular. Suddenly, people are going to realize that album U2 forced on the public was pretty decent after all. It might take another decade for that to happen or the death of Bono but I think it’s going to happen.
    No chance !! Rightly or wrongly the album is tainted with the forced iPod fiasco. Personally I think they album is one of their worst. Much prefer SOE.
  10. Originally posted by bpt3:Can't believe this was over 9 years ago. I remember feeling...underwhelmed.

    Thank goodness for the I&E Tour, which made me appreciate SOI a little more. But EBW, California, Cedarwood, and Troubles are really the only songs I go back to anymore from this album. I haven't listened to it all the way through in years and don't really feel the need to do so.


    Still feel the same a year later. I want to like this album more but just never really have. Telling stories about your upbringing while using modern producers is an intriguing idea, sure. But, despite its overall cohesiveness, it just feels mainly monochrome, bland, and uninspiring. It's clear they got nervous after NLOTH and musically resorted to something a lot safer.

    Loved the I&E/E&I tours though. SOI sounded a lot better live, even if EBW and Cedarwood are probably the only songs I'd ever care to hear again at a show.
  11. “SOE is better than SOI” it’s for dumb people