1. The shows I went to I had a great time - but hey, it's a U2 show so that should be a given, right

    I understand that U2 is a business and they had commitments to play these shows (?) but people are quick to call the Oasis reunion a 'cash cow' - and to be fair it is but that doesn't mean that the brothers haven't made up with each other and the fans will have an awesome time but let's call a spade a spade here - but this tour had 'cash cow' written all over it too

    I was more than happy to go to this tour cash cow or not, but the setlist was the problem for me

    Whilst it was great to hear some of the classics again - Exit particularly was mega awesome but I just expected to like OTH, RTSS and MOTD more than I did - and RHMT was, well, let's just not go there

    The tour should have been an era led concept with RAH and b-sides making up the rest of the show - the placement of all the hits especially post RAH did not work for me

    The original JT tours , the PopMart tours, the ZOO tours and even the Elevation and 360 tours all have their die-hard advocates but does anyone really think about this tour with warmth nostalgia as we do those?

    Maybe they should rename it 'The Forgettable Tour'
  2. I personally loved this tour as I got to hear my favourite album played live in full.
  3. Same here. The Rome concert was one of the best concerts nights I've ever had.
  4. 2017 was better than 2019. Although 2019 did have some great performances. Stuck in Sydney. Gloria for the last shows. Bad in Mumbai.

    London 1 in 2017 was great for me. Rail spot at the b-stage. Bad/Little Things the band right in front of me next to Larry.

    My perspective, this guy was right next to me...

  5. Originally posted by RedSky:The shows I went to I had a great time - but hey, it's a U2 show so that should be a given, right

    I understand that U2 is a business and they had commitments to play these shows (?) but people are quick to call the Oasis reunion a 'cash cow' - and to be fair it is but that doesn't mean that the brothers haven't made up with each other and the fans will have an awesome time but let's call a spade a spade here - but this tour had 'cash cow' written all over it too

    I was more than happy to go to this tour cash cow or not, but the setlist was the problem for me

    Whilst it was great to hear some of the classics again - Exit particularly was mega awesome but I just expected to like OTH, RTSS and MOTD more than I did - and RHMT was, well, let's just not go there

    The tour should have been an era led concept with RAH and b-sides making up the rest of the show - the placement of all the hits especially post RAH did not work for me

    The original JT tours , the PopMart tours, the ZOO tours and even the Elevation and 360 tours all have their die-hard advocates but does anyone really think about this tour with warmth nostalgia as we do those?

    Maybe they should rename it 'The Forgettable Tour'
    They had an obligation to do a tour yes, but the originally announced two legs was sufficient to fulfil those contractual obligations. (And they could have done it with less shows.) The latter two legs, and the 2019 shows were all because U2 wanted to do them and not out of any sort of commitment to Live Nation. And the whole 2019 leg was far from a money maker for them. Weak currency exchange, difficulty selling out shows, the cost of lugging the stage and tour crews the distances that they did.

    I loved the shows I did. But they do blend together a bit, because that Joshua Tree portion in the middle never changed. I had some highlights. Seattle, second show of the tour, hit a high point that the rest of the tour never really hit for me. I got to see guests on stage like Marcus Mumford and Eddie Vedder, and later in the tour, Patti Smith. I got to see "Spanish Eyes", which was great. Overall I probably enjoyed the shows a bit more than the IE / EI shows.
  6. Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:2017 was better than 2019. Although 2019 did have some great performances. Stuck in Sydney. Gloria for the last shows. Bad in Mumbai.

    London 1 in 2017 was great for me. Rail spot at the b-stage. Bad/Little Things the band right in front of me next to Larry.

    My perspective, this guy was right next to me...

    [YouTube Video]
    For me, it was the exact opposite. In 2017, they were playing on autopilot, while in 2019, they seemed to be having a lot of fun. And the setlist had minor changes in 2019 which made it better.
  7. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:[..]
    For me, it was the exact opposite. In 2017, they were playing on autopilot, while in 2019, they seemed to be having a lot of fun. And the setlist had minor changes in 2019 which made it better.
    That's true. Larry was more into it in 2019. Speaking on stage!
  8. Yeh, I'm not beating down on the tour - or the band - and I was at both Twickenham gigs (saw Coldplay the same week in Cardiff) and had a great time with the first day in the stands so I could enjoy the spectacle of the screen (impressive) and the second in the red zone so I could enjoy Bono and the boys close up - and Noel Gallagher too (who always looks like he's in pain)

    It just didn't excite me as much as those legendary tours even though it is a legendary album

    And I take on board Aaron's points about later in the tour the band wanted to do those dates and maybe they weren't as profitable also - maybe that's why they did loosen up a bit more later on

    But I will forever be grateful to the tour for giving me that awesome performance of Exit if nothing else
  9. I attended four shows, and 'A Sort of Homecoming' was played at two of them — a nice record. Good times!
  10. Speaking on stage. Meeting with fans. Signing autographs. Hosting a movie night. Seeing him laughing and enjoying an evening with fans was nice. He really seemed to be having fun both on and off stage.
  11. Originally posted by Zwervervriend:[..]
    For me, it was the exact opposite. In 2017, they were playing on autopilot, while in 2019, they seemed to be having a lot of fun. And the setlist had minor changes in 2019 which made it better.
    In retrospect, is it possible that Bono was still recovering from the Dec 2016 heart surgery / scare when the JT17 Tour began? I was at the Vancouver Opener and remember thinking the energy was a bit off and it wasn't just opening night nervousness. I was at Seattle which was a great show for reasons already mentioned. JT19 had a higher energy level though; I persomally saw this at the San Diego show.
  12. There is for me. I saw the 2017 tour at Twickenham, it was their first concert of the tour in Europe and compared to the US the crowd were much more energetic and engaging. You could see the band were getting off on it.

    We got the whole Joshua Tree album played live and in sequence, plus for me a dream setlist with Ultra Violet and Bad in the mix. I had also lost my dad that year in January, he was a huge Bowie fan passing away almost a year after Bowie did. When Bono did the Heroes snippet in Bad it really got to me.

    Overall one of the best concerts I've ever attended. The show felt fresh despite being an anniversary of a past album, it had it's own energy and atmosphere.