1. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:[..]
    I hold belief that this duo will get the job done and not be persuaded or settle for mediocrity. They must have got over some hurdles to have Eno work with the band again after the ‘ so called ‘ feud they ( band and Eno ) had over ‘credits’ on previous albums ( I think it was NLOTH or AB ). Someone will know the particulars.
    ALTYCLB I think it was but McGuinness wasn't having any of it as he said Eno was hired solely as a producer not a songwriter for that album ,however they did give him and Lanois songwriting credits on NOLOTH probably to appease them and not burn their bridges for future albums.


  2. Glad Eno’s involved. I heard Tonky by Lonnie Holley (after Bono mentioned it), which Lee produced, and since Holley just does spoken word it’s basically all Lee. He’s good but a bit predictable. With Eno we might get the best of both worlds. Of course, Edge and Duncan Stewart are probably also helping out with production.


  3. Both of them together? Have the band album with Jacknife and "Irish sci fi folk" Eno/Bono/Edge prokect blended into one album?
  4. Originally posted by popmarter:[..]
    ALTYCLB I think it was but McGuinness wasn't having any of it as he said Eno was hired solely as a producer not a songwriter for that album ,however they did give him and Lanois songwriting credits on NOLOTH probably to appease them and not burn their bridges for future albums.
    Ahh thanks for the correction 🙂

    Just keep Edge away from that mixing board!! For the love of god!
  5. The "dispute with Eno" started after Atomic Bomb was released. He made a few comments about songwriting that had gotten a bit of notice.

    From a 2007 Q Magazine interview with Eno, where I first saw mention of it:

    Q Magazine: "All That You Can't Leave Behind sounded less Eno-influenced than the other albums..."

    Eno: "What I provided were not songs, but... very provocative starting points. Dan [Lanois, co-producer] and I got into a habit of getting into the studio first thing in the morning, so that when they walked in, there was already something happening."

    Q Magazine: "There were rumours you'd fallen out with U2..."

    Eno: "We didn't really fall out, but I was quite upset when All That You Can't Leave Behind came out and on the credits it said under each song, 'Music by U2', without mentioning that I'd made a contribution. I wasn't asking for more money. But credits, man, it doesn't cost you anything. But anyway that was all a long time ago and I've forgotten about it now."

    Q Magazine: "Will you work together again?"

    Eno: "I'm sure we will at some time, yeah."

    In the book On Some Faraway Beach which came out around the time No Line was released it contained the following passage.

    "After the release of How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb, Brian Eno had his first substantial falling out with Bono and co. The problem was an old bug bear, writing credits. Anthea (his wife and manager) told me that Brian was upset that he hadn't recevied a share of the authorship on many of hte songs he felt he'd helped sculpt on the band's recent albums. U2, famously, always kept songwriting within the group (Passengers album being one notable exception.) It was not, Anthea stressed, a matter of royalty payments per se (Brian apparently still refused to be told what he's being paid for such major projects), but one of author recognition. Subsequently, Bono phoned Brain to offer an olive branch. On the next U2 record, the band would contravene their own rule and begin by co-writing with Brian (a process that began in Morocco in 2007)"

    The band have gone to him a number of times in the in-between years. At one point they approached him to work on "The Little Things That Give You Away" and now he appears to be back in studio with them having worked on the new material. So it sounds like they got past any real beef that they had...
  6. Isnt that the way they always worked together? Eno and Lanois offering ideas and playing with the band? And they are credited in album liner notes under "synthezisers/programing" in Eno's case and "additional guitar" for Lanois?

    Also... Pretty sure songwriting credits iinclude money.

  7. Yes indeed... met Brian at Tegel Airport after Berlin 3 in 2018 😉
  8. edit: double post
  9. Whoever decided it was a good idea to have Vertigo before Streets for the Sphere shows is an idiot imo. It does not work in the slightest and is completely jarring. They try and add the "epic/emotional" element with the MOS snippet but even that doesn't really belong following Vertigo. Just adds to the "jukebox" feel encore and the "we've played you Achtung Baby, now here's some of our other big hits in no particular order". One of the reasons why I don't listen into the encore when listening to these shows.
  10. Originally posted by jc25:Whoever decided it was a good idea to have Vertigo before Streets for the Sphere shows is an idiot imo. It does not work in the slightest and is completely jarring. They try and add the "epic/emotional" element with the MOS snippet but even that doesn't really belong following Vertigo. Just adds to the "jukebox" feel encore and the "we've played you Achtung Baby, now here's some of our other big hits in no particular order". One of the reasons why I don't listen into the encore when listening to these shows.
    Maybe 2 encores could have fixed that. Having a break then the full intro to streets and the whole screen of sphere turns red like they did with JT 17/19 tour.
  11. Originally posted by jc25:Whoever decided it was a good idea to have Vertigo before Streets for the Sphere shows is an idiot imo. It does not work in the slightest and is completely jarring. They try and add the "epic/emotional" element with the MOS snippet but even that doesn't really belong following Vertigo. Just adds to the "jukebox" feel encore and the "we've played you Achtung Baby, now here's some of our other big hits in no particular order". One of the reasons why I don't listen into the encore when listening to these shows.
    Agree.
  12. Originally posted by jc25:Whoever decided it was a good idea to have Vertigo before Streets for the Sphere shows is an idiot imo. It does not work in the slightest and is completely jarring. They try and add the "epic/emotional" element with the MOS snippet but even that doesn't really belong following Vertigo. Just adds to the "jukebox" feel encore and the "we've played you Achtung Baby, now here's some of our other big hits in no particular order". One of the reasons why I don't listen into the encore when listening to these shows.
    Ugh absolutely.

    Maybe have Vertigo into Beautiful Day, then transition that into Streets. Then WOWY and 40 to finish every show.