1. Discotheque was embarrassing then and it's embarrassing now


  2. Nah - it's what people really think is U2's worst song to them

    You want to get subjective and break down the minutia of every single note, lyric, idea, inflection, what key it's in, the production, its heart, its soul?

    That doesn't matter - it's simple if someone thinks that the song sucks (to them) then it sucks

    So maybe change the thread title but I'm telling you now, to me, Magnificent is the antithesis of its titular adornment

    Slow, labouring, feels like it's dragging itself through treacle - not 'Magnificent' to these ears

    One of the last things we have control over is our opinion - for now - so let people have their say

    It's a song in the end - no one is getting bombed out of their homes for profit or shot in the face by their own countrymen
  3. The entire SOE album
  4. Originally posted by RedSky:[..]


    Nah - it's what people really think is U2's worst song to them

    You want to get subjective and break down the minutia of every single note, lyric, idea, inflection, what key it's in, the production, its heart, its soul?

    That doesn't matter - it's simple if someone thinks that the song sucks (to them) then it sucks

    So maybe change the thread title but I'm telling you now, to me, Magnificent is the antithesis of its titular adornment

    Slow, labouring, feels like it's dragging itself through treacle - not 'Magnificent' to these ears

    One of the last things we have control over is our opinion - for now - so let people have their say

    It's a song in the end - no one is getting bombed out of their homes for profit or shot in the face by their own countrymen
    Well said. Also agree with Magnificent, I think tempo was an issue.
  5. Originally posted by Peterrrrr:Stand Up Comedy..

    ...and Beautiful Day, one of their worst studio tracks ever.
    It way better live.
    But this track was the first Commercial Adult Rock that started everything, those kind of tracks has been on every album since then.


    SUC is in the top 5 duds. The Refugee is better than most are giving it credit for here.
  6. I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For

    (Of course not, I think this is one of the songs that each one of us loves)
  7. Originally posted by RedSky:[..]


    Nah - it's what people really think is U2's worst song to them

    You want to get subjective and break down the minutia of every single note, lyric, idea, inflection, what key it's in, the production, its heart, its soul?

    That doesn't matter - it's simple if someone thinks that the song sucks (to them) then it sucks

    So maybe change the thread title but I'm telling you now, to me, Magnificent is the antithesis of its titular adornment

    Slow, labouring, feels like it's dragging itself through treacle - not 'Magnificent' to these ears

    One of the last things we have control over is our opinion - for now - so let people have their say

    It's a song in the end - no one is getting bombed out of their homes for profit or shot in the face by their own countrymen
    Thank you for helping me put into words what I've always felt was OFF about "Magnificent". I don't think it's their worst song or anything, but I never thought it was very good.

    The band must've felt similarly about it. It was eventually dropped from the 360 tour by the end. They tried it once on the 2015 tour, and then abandoned it once again, never to return.
  8. It's hilarious it didn't work out during Elevation Tour, which Bono's voice was better, and Vertigo Tour, which the band was in it's prime time.


  9. Agree.
  10. If You Wear That Velvet Dress
    Cedars Of Lebanon
    Atomic City
    Your Song Saved My Life
    Ahimsa
  11. Grace and Your Song Saved My Life