1. Originally posted by SJKamal:Days of Ash and Easter Lily seem to be generally well received by the U2 fandom. When was the last time new music was well received by all fans?
    ATYCLB
  2. Haha. Then never because with each album you will find that one person that is not happy 😛
  3. What was the poll on atU2.com in between Pop and ATYCLB?

    "What song would you most like the new album to sound like?"

    I think the winner was Mofo.
  4. Originally posted by Welsh_Edge:What was the poll on atU2.com in between Pop and ATYCLB?

    "What song would you most like the new album to sound like?"

    I think the winner was Mofo.
    Yes, ATYCLB was quite a departure, like The Unforgettable Fire and Achtung Baby before it. Mofo was just that song that U2 hardcore fans were expected to hype at the time but U2 changed direction and proved them wrong ultimately.

    Is Easter Lily a similar departure? I’m not sure. It’s more of a continuation of the best U2 has done in the past than a new direction. They seem very calm and at peace with their past music, maybe for the first time ever.
  5. With how well received the two EPs have been, I've been wondering if SOI and SOE would be thought of more favourably if they were released as smaller collections of songs too. Has anyone ever thought about what an innocence or experience EP might look like? Or even a NLOTH one?
  6. Originally posted by yoshino_blossom:With how well received the two EPs have been, I've been wondering if SOI and SOE would be thought of more favourably if they were released as smaller collections of songs too. Has anyone ever thought about what an innocence or experience EP might look like? Or even a NLOTH one?
    NLOTH EP

    . Fez/Being Born
    . Unknown Caller
    . Moment Of Surrender
    . No Line On The Horizon
    . Breathe
    . Winter

    I'd have to think about SOI and SOE. I couldn't condense them down to EP's. One album maybe.
  7. If SOE was an EP with only The Blackout and Little Things it would be the best EP ever
  8. SOI EP:
    1. Every Breaking Wave
    2. California (There Is No End To Love)
    3. Song For Someone
    4. Iris (Hold Me Close)
    5. The Crystal Ballroom
    6. The Troubles
    + Invisible (hidden track)

    SOE EP:
    1. Lights of Home
    2. The Little Things That Give You Away
    3. Landlady
    4. The Blackout
    5. Ordinary Love (Extraordinary Mix)
    6. Book of Your Heart
  9. Originally posted by Bonu:SOI EP:
    1. Every Breaking Wave
    2. California (There Is No End To Love)
    3. Song For Someone
    4. Iris (Hold Me Close)
    5. The Crystal Ballroom
    6. The Troubles
    + Invisible (hidden track)

    SOE EP:
    1. Lights of Home
    2. The Little Things That Give You Away
    3. Landlady
    4. The Blackout
    5. Ordinary Love (Extraordinary Mix)
    6. Book of Your Heart
    Well done!

    I'll open SOE with Blackout
  10. Achtung Baby was a slow burner and they lost some old die hard fans at the time because of the dramatic change in musical direction which was too much for some who preferred the big anthems and fist pumping approach to their music, It wasn't until they took it on the road with Zoo TV that people really started getting into it and appreciating what a great album it was.
  11. Originally posted by Bonu:[..]
    Yes, ATYCLB was quite a departure, like The Unforgettable Fire and Achtung Baby before it. Mofo was just that song that U2 hardcore fans were expected to hype at the time but U2 changed direction and proved them wrong ultimately.

    Is Easter Lily a similar departure? I’m not sure. It’s more of a continuation of the best U2 has done in the past than a new direction. They seem very calm and at peace with their past music, maybe for the first time ever.
    War into Unforgettable Fire into Joshua Tree is an amazing and mind-blowing run and change in style/sonics if you think about it

    how did that felt in the fanbase back then?