Considering the 50th anniversary and longstanding success and unchanged lineup, would you agree that U2 are within History's Top 3 Greatest Rock & Roll bands? (Alongside The Beatles and Rolling Stones)
If not, do you think that, if they make this next album a masterpiece, they can claim that Top 3 spot?
I think they are among the great bands and have certainly had one of the most remarkable careers. They are MY favorite band.
But they came too late to be ranked with the Beatles and Stones, which are the bands that sort of defined what rock and roll became afterwards. And they are only kind of a "rock & roll" band.
In my opinion they probably are. However they aren't culturally relevant enough to be considered in the top 3 by the general public. Stones, Queen and Beatles probably are the 3.
Originally posted by SJKamal:In my opinion they probably are. However they aren't culturally relevant enough to be considered in the top 3 by the general public. Stones, Queen and Beatles probably are the 3.
This is just like the "which albums are masterpieces" discussion.
It's easy to say the Beatles (and maybe the Stones given their subsequent influence and longevity) are the greatest.
After that, there are lots of great bands, but no clear consensus as to supremacy: Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, the Doors, the Dead, Queen, the Velvet Underground, the Clash, Nirvana, U2...