Except, as I've said before, when they actually were "relevant" and "current" in their golden era, they did it with challenging, unique music that sounded little like what anyone else was making. The album that made them superstars is still a brilliant one off: no one (including them) has ever made anything like the Joshua Tree. With Achtung Baby they clearly borrowed from all kinds of influences to, once again, make an utterly unique and unrepeatable masterpiece.
Nowhere on either of those albums does it sound like they are making a bid to be "current". Rather, those albums helped to define what was "current" by being so awesome and forward looking.
And before anyone tells me to stop living in the past, what is the point for any artist if it is not to make something new while at least trying to equal (if not surpass) what you have already achieved?
Meh it's not 1986 when they were still relatively new. Their inspirations, motivations and obligations have changed. They've raised kids, dealt with injuries and illnesses and have spent a long time playing music. So, they're making something new now and getting dragged for it. They got dragged a fair bit by fans when JT, AB and Pop came out, and it's bound to happen again. I'm just happy they have made a body of music that they can agree on again as a whole and call an album. I can't speak for their motivation, but I'd wager that they don't want to try to make a JT 2.0 or AB 2.0. Who would have thought that in 2026 U2 would release songs with Latin flair and an EDM collaboration? Not me.. but if it keeps them interested and creating, I'm all for it
I don't know... It sounds very simple and pretentious. Very linear. Easter Lily gave me a glimmer of hope. We don't need to walk the same path over and over again with every new release from the band. I hope they're just scamming us with the bait.
The best thing for the band is to go back into studio, remove all equipment that are younger than from 1997.
Record all songs in a analogue studio, use electric gear like Roland keybaords, Moog, TB-303 and their ordinary instruments.
They need to remove all this overproduced 2010-2026-ish digtal chewguum sound that every artis have these days.
This (version of this) track has its HTDAAB moments - and it's nice to hear a guitar in there somewhere these days - so it's not terrible and I've heard much worse
Collaborations are always gonna happen and we should accept that - though we may not be happy with it
@Peterrrrrr I agree with the chewing gum (bubble gum) analogy but we're not inside the band's heads and in their heads they are happy with what they're doing - I'd rather see a mature, darker, more daring side to the music but whatyagonnado?
This song is making me think: if they finally decided to finish some songs in Pop and release it next year with modern sounds ( to mark the 30 anniversary) it would sound very fresh
The beginning of Fireflies sounds so much like Velvet Dress, that song could be amazing if re-recorded and re-released next year with some other Pop songs
Originally posted by juandicorrea:The beginning of Fireflies sounds so much like Velvet Dress, that song could be amazing if re-recorded and re-released next year with some other Pop songs
I hope they don’t decide to re-record Pop. The redo in 2002 was bad enough.