1. Listening on headphones now - Bono's voice sounds great, and the falsetto in the chorus is perfect.
  2. why ?
  3. Charity? At least 50% of royalties are going to Simon Community, which U2 have supported in the past, helping the Homeless in Dublin?

    Friendship? Bono was close to MacGowan, even letting him live at his guest house while he was recovering at one point. He's participated in a number of MacGowan projects before his death, and I'm sure he jumped when MacGowan's wife asked the band to be a part of this.
  4. Didn’t he slag Bono or U2 off in his final years , not a fan of the guy personally he was an abuser and generally horrible person from all accounts.
  5. .
  6. Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:Didn’t he slag Bono or U2 off in his final years , not a fan of the guy personally he was an abuser and generally horrible person from all accounts.
    Bono sang with MacGowan as part of the 60th birthday show they held for Shane in 2018, and Bono was one of the featured "friends" in the 2020 documentary "Crock of Gold". His wife shared in 2022, "They are very close. Bono is almost reverential to Shane, it’s very sweet. And it helps keep him (Shane) going when he’s maybe a bit under the weather. Their friendship means a lot." That was the year before Shane passed. So if there was any issues there seems they were resolved before his final years.

    It was back in the early 2000 that Bono offered Shane a home at his guest house in Dublin, while Shane was recovering from addiction. There was apparently some tensions there towards the end of that stay, but they seemed friendly enough on and off during the years.
  7. I highly recommend watching the Shane McGowan doc before jugding him.
  8. Love this cover version, bzw.
    Sounds like 4 people in a room, nice guitar work.
  9. It's a cover - it's a tribute - it's nothing more

    No need to hate it but it's transient and throw-away

    Won't be listening to it again in a hurry
  10. I think it is quotes like this "I was ashamed I didn't have the guts to join the IRA, and the Pogues was my way of overcoming that" that many people have an issue with as it could have been seen as "Glorifying the revolution" as our own Bono had the guts to say

    But The Troubles is very misunderstood by the majority of people on both sides of the argument and horrendous atrocities were committed equally

    I've posted before about a documentary on The Troubles, called Once Upon a Time in Northern Ireland, that people should watch before judging any one side - it's an eye-opener and not just for the viewer but for the people who took part also as they too undergo an 'awakening' and a self- exploration

    As a Brit I took my own prejudices with me into that documentary and came out a different person, a better person, with a different view

    Regarding the addiction problems and how he could be 'difficult' - well, I guess we have to admit that there's some truth in that
  11. Of course. Addiction is a serious illness which has an effect on one's actions. I don't intend to apologize anything - but knowing about trauma and addiction helps to unterstand why some people behave in a certain way.
  12. The percussion was an interesting choice.