1. My lord I could listen to this all day.
  2. I have.
  3. Listen to that instrumental
  4. This song alone justifies a new U2 album. It’s incredible.

    No idea if it can achieve broader pop or music culture popularity in today’s media landscape, but it certainly deserves it.

    I cannot wait to hear it live. Going to be special.
  5. This band has no business being this good at this stage of their career. They're a phenomenon. If this was the last song released this year I'd be completely happy. So excited to hear the rest of the album. We're being spoiled finally after the long wait. I'm elated.
  6. It’s got an amazing vibe all on its own without any vocals. Imagine being Bono and having to fit around that, im amazed he can do that time after time. It’s like a sequel to WOWY or EBW, I think it’s as strong a composition as those. It’s got that longing feeling of the former I think it might be more heartbreaking.
  7. i feel this song it’s like a goodbye
  8. Is this song stronger than Every Breaking Wave, Moment of Surrender, and The Little Things That Gove You Away?

    Perhaps…
  9. If we do a LP of the best of U2 post 2000, it would stand on par with Unforgettable Fire, Joshua Tree, and Achtung Baby.

    Beautiful Day
    Walk On
    Kite
    City of Blinding Lights
    Sometimes You Can’t Make It On Your Own
    Mercy
    Moment of Surrender
    Every Breaking Wave
    The Little Things That Give You Away
    The Tears of Things
    Resurrection Song
    The Greatest Show On Earth

    And I think that’s a truly great achievement.
  10. I don’t think this is a ‘goodbye’ as such ( maybe if this song was also rejected by the masses ) but that’s clearly not the case. I have a group of mates that fell of the u2 apple cart one by one over the past two decades, those mates have jumped back on that apple cart. The response to the song has been overwhelmingly positive.

    As for what the songs true meaning is? For mine it’s about love but underneath that sentiment I think this song is about ‘THEM’ in the video the very first time Bono croons “ we were once the greatest show on earth “ he invites the camera to move left and as it does the camera refocuses on the band playing behind him. It’s subtle but it’s there.

    This is a message that they still desperately want to be the ‘biggest band in the world’.
  11. …