Originally posted by EdgeMedia72:I don’t think this is a ‘goodbye’ as such ( maybe if this song was also rejected by the masses ) but that’s clearly not the case. I have a group of mates that fell of the u2 apple cart one by one over the past two decades, those mates have jumped back on that apple cart. The response to the song has been overwhelmingly positive.
As for what the songs true meaning is? For mine it’s about love but underneath that sentiment I think this song is about ‘THEM’ in the video the very first time Bono croons “ we were once the greatest show on earth “ he invites the camera to move left and as it does the camera refocuses on the band playing behind him. It’s subtle but it’s there.
This is a message that they still desperately want to be the ‘biggest band in the world’.
The music video is likely about them—showing how they are trying to rebuild upon the remnants of the past. Is it an aging "The Fly" returning to tell us that, despite appearances, they aren't finished yet? Does his transformation into a white suit at the end signify that he is no longer as cynical as he once was? And are the symbols being carried around the relics of the joshua tree and Zoo TV era? There are many strong nostalgic elements here, with an underlying sense of melancholy as well.
I think a lot of the future of this band going forward depends on health issues. Bono’s heart surgery from several years ago and than his bicycle accident that also took several surgeries to repair his arm and eye socket, he’s also got glaucoma, Larry’s depending back and spinal surgery, we will see how much and far he can go drumming, so you add these up at the age of 66 and 64, yea you start reflecting on the past and wonder how much gas is left in the tank
After a busy weekend I finally go to listened to it again since release day and this time a wave came over me the song hit me. I now have it on repeat and humming along
I think SOE was in many ways more of a goodbye than this. I don't think they are done. And just because they only announced six shows doesn't mean that there is a boat load of shows coming.
Looking at the entire U2 career there is a strong pattern of three albums for each era for the band. So far they never failed to follow this pattern.
1. Boy, October, War - post-punk beginnings
2. The Unforgettable Fire, The Joshua Tree, Rattle & Hum - classical period
3. Achtung Baby, Zooropa, Pop - electronic music
4. All That You Can’t Leave Behind, How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, No Line On The Horizon - neo-classical period
5. Songs Of Innocence, Songs Of Experience, Songs Of Surrender - retrospective, coming back to early days period
6. Carnaval De Luz - whatever it ends up being, it’s only a start of the new beginning and new era for the band
Originally posted by Bonu:Looking at the entire U2 career there is a strong pattern of three albums for each era for the band. So far they never failed to follow this pattern.
1. Boy, October, War - post-punk beginnings
2. The Unforgettable Fire, The Joshua Tree, Rattle & Hum - classical period
3. Achtung Baby, Zooropa, Pop - electronic music
4. All That You Can’t Leave Behind, How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, No Line On The Horizon - neo-classical period
5. Songs Of Innocence, Songs Of Experience, Songs Of Surrender - retrospective, coming back to early days period
6. Carnaval De Luz - whatever it ends up being, it’s only a start of the new beginning and new era for the band
Maybe it is:
6. Days of Ash, Easter Lily and Carnaval De Luz?
Originally posted by Bonu:Looking at the entire U2 career there is a strong pattern of three albums for each era for the band. So far they never failed to follow this pattern.
1. Boy, October, War - post-punk beginnings
2. The Unforgettable Fire, The Joshua Tree, Rattle & Hum - classical period
3. Achtung Baby, Zooropa, Pop - electronic music
4. All That You Can’t Leave Behind, How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb, No Line On The Horizon - neo-classical period
5. Songs Of Innocence, Songs Of Experience, Songs Of Surrender - retrospective, coming back to early days period
6. Carnaval De Luz - whatever it ends up being, it’s only a start of the new beginning and new era for the band
Yeah, CDL is a new era. But Taylor Swift stole the word 'era' from U2 and it is time for U2 to steal it "baaaack".
I absolutely love this part of the song ( lyrically and video ).
Love is a business that works at night
I sold myself for less than was right
You taught me what I was worth
In the greatest show on earth
Made a profession out of breaking your heart
You call it lies, I call it art
The other thing I have noticed in that clip is that Bono really has confidence back, it borders on that 90s swagger and arrogance that has been so sorely missing for two decades. This is a man who is saying don’t challenge us we can be the best in the world again. I’ve had enough of the introspective and humble Bono ( save that for your twilight years ) let’s roll with this earnest confidence. I mean he has copped the ‘head up his arse’ tag all thru that period of reflection and being humble and it never really changed the ‘haters’ opinion of him … can’t beat em join em I say! Double down even!!
Originally posted by kharbouch:[..]
The music video is likely about them—showing how they are trying to rebuild upon the remnants of the past. Is it an aging "The Fly" returning to tell us that, despite appearances, they aren't finished yet?
Your right this could so easily be an older ‘the fly’!!
Originally posted by siblis55:I think a lot of the future of this band going forward depends on health issues. Bono’s heart surgery from several years ago and than his bicycle accident that also took several surgeries to repair his arm and eye socket, he’s also got glaucoma, Larry’s depending back and spinal surgery, we will see how much and far he can go drumming, so you add these up at the age of 66 and 64, yea you start reflecting on the past and wonder how much gas is left in the tank
Bono looks awesome and as fit and in shape as he has since the original JT Tour ( excluding the early POP period ).
Since then age has started to catch up.
He has always carried a little bit of weight being a shorter man and the excesses of the ‘rock n roll’ life will do that to you.
You can now see he takes his body seriously now.
Mean-while check out clips of The Edge during ZooTv , he has a skinny guy, over the years The Edge has packed on muscle and clearly works out and is still very fit. I’m sure they will all be able to play 2hr tops shows every night on this tour. I think the shows in South America will be somewhat of testing ground to see what they are capable off and they will ramp it up accordingly by the time they get to Europe and North America.
Bono maintains his weight very well, I wouldn't even describe him as even having a 'little bit of weight', Edge has been the most vital member of U2 post-2020.